Pjetër Shala, sentenced by the Specialist Court of Appeals to 13 years in prison, has appealed to the Constitutional Court, which operates as a unit within the Specialist Chambers. Shala claims that his rights to a fair trial have been violated. The complaint concerns the defence's argument that the order for 208 thousand euros in compensation to victims was issued before “the decision sentencing him had become final”.

“The Defence was required to file a Notice of Appeal against the Reparation Order by 29 January 2025, while the Appeal Judgment on the merits of the case was issued only on 14 July 2025 – several months after the deadline for the Notice of Appeal and the Defence Appeal Brief against the Reparation Order, which had to be filed by 14 March 2025,” Shala's complaint states.

DOCUMENT:

The Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court had found that Shala had sufficient time and procedural opportunity to file his appeal concerning reparations to the victims. However, the defence says that the decision on compensation should have been issued after the Court of Appeals' decision on the case as a whole.

Furthermore, Shala also claims that the Specialist Court “has not sufficiently established the legal and factual connection between the crimes for which Mr Shala was convicted and the categories of harm for which he was ordered to compensate the victims”.

“The Trial Panel's own reasoning demonstrates the importance of this issue. With regard to W04733's health condition, the Trial Panel acknowledged that not all aspects of the deterioration in his health over the years were a direct result of the crimes. Nevertheless, it concluded that the brutality of the crimes and W04733's condition after returning home may ‘have had an aggravating effect’ on his health”, Shala's complaint states.

DOCUMENT:

Pjetër Shala's claims also concern the amount awarded in reparations to the victims. According to him, there is insufficient evidence establishing a link between the harm caused to the victims and the amount set as compensation.

“The Reparation Order awarded 30,000 euros for W04733's medical expenses. The evidentiary material includes estimates of medical expenses, including testimony from W04733 and W03/04. The Appeals Panel notes that W04733 and W03/04 submitted estimates, one of which amounted to as much as 150,000 euros. The existence of these estimates does not prove that 30,000 euros was the amount established by the evidence. Therefore, the fundamental question is: why 30,000 euros?”, the complaint adds.

Pjetër Shala was sentenced to 13 years' imprisonment by the Specialist Court. The trial court had initially sentenced him to 18 years in prison, but the sentence was reduced by five years on appeal.

The Trial Panel had ordered Pjetër Shala to pay a sum of 208,000 euros in compensation for the physical, mental and material harm caused to the victims of the crimes of which he was found guilty.

Shala had also challenged the compensation decision before both the Appeals Court and the Supreme Court of the Specialist Court.