Sixty-three days have passed since the guilty verdict against Hashim Thaçi, Kadri Veseli, Jakup Krasniqi and Rexhep Selimi, but the public has still not read the full judgment, its reasoning or the evidence on which it was based.
The defense, meanwhile, outraged by the total of 81 years in prison handed down to the four KLA leaders, as well as by a trial widely contested over violations and bias, has called for the evidence and the reasoning behind the verdict to be made public as soon as possible.
In a response to VOX Kosova, officials of the Specialist Chambers did not provide a specific date or approximate timeline for when the judgment, which runs to more than 2,000 pages, might be made public.
“The public redacted version of the full judgment is being prepared expeditiously, ensuring that as much information as possible is made public while also guaranteeing the protection of witnesses and victims. The full public redacted version of the judgment will be published as soon as possible,” Michael Doyle said.
“The length of the judgment and the relevant procedural steps may affect the time of its publication… There is no delay. The Trial Panel is determining the timelines to ensure that this process proceeds as quickly as possible,” he said.
When the Court of Appeals set several deadlines for filing appeals, it also referred to the judgment, highlighting the complexity of the case.
The Appeals Panel noted that the conviction of the KLA leaders by the Trial Panel involved a large number of crime scenes and incidents committed across the territory of 16 municipalities, in six KLA operational zones in Kosovo, as well as in certain parts of northern Albania, between at least April 1998 and June 20, 1999.
“The Trial Panel also notes the length of the Trial Judgment, namely 2,089 pages—the longest judgment ever issued by the Specialist Chambers—as well as the considerable complexity of this case, arising, among other things, from the scope of the Indictment and the leadership roles of the Accused alleged in the Indictment,” the Appeals decision published several weeks ago stated.
But how long did it take to publish the judgments in the cases of Salih Mustafa and Pjetër Shala?
In Salih Mustafa’s case, the judgment was announced on December 16, 2022, while the Court announced on January 19, 2023, that the redacted English version was available to the public. In other words, 34 days passed between the announcement and the publication of the public redacted version.
In Pjetër Shala’s case, the judgment was announced on July 16, 2024, while the public redacted version in English was published on September 24, 2024. In this case, 70 days passed before publication.
However, the cases of Mustafa and Shala were significantly smaller in terms of the volume of evidence, geographic scope and time period compared with the case against the KLA leaders.
This may mean that publishing the full redacted version in the latter case could take more time.
The volume of the case file also affected how long it took the Trial Panel to deliver its judgment after the parties’ closing statements.
In Mustafa’s case, the verdict was announced 92 days after the closing statements concluded.
In Pjetër Shala’s case, it was 90 days. Meanwhile, in the case of the KLA leaders, the wait lasted 210 days, from February 18 to September 16, 2026.
On Tuesday, the Trial Court sentenced Hashim Thaçi to 17 months in prison for obstruction of justice. Bashkim Smakaj, Fadil Fazliu and Hajredin Kuçi were also found guilty, but were released due to time already served in detention or suspended sentences. Isni Kilaj, meanwhile, was found not guilty.
One of the judges on the Trial Panel in the case of the KLA leaders, Guénaël Mettraux, has applied for a judgeship at the International Court of Justice.
VOX Kosova asked the Specialist Court whether the voting process expected to take place soon could be a factor in the delay in publishing the judgment, with the aim of avoiding controversy before the vote.
“Matters unrelated to the judicial proceedings in this case have no bearing on the timing of the publication of the judgment or on any other decision of the Trial Panel,” spokesperson Michael Doyle said.
The Specialist Court has been repeatedly criticized for its lack of transparency and the pronounced secrecy of the judicial process, both in hearings and in access to documents and evidence.
This lack of transparency has also been highlighted by the accused themselves and their defense teams. Lawyers have described the trial of the KLA leaders as a “secret trial.”









