There is a widely held belief among the international legal community in The Hague, who have followed the trial of the KLA leaders, that the architect of the appalling and condemnatory judgment is the Swiss judge, Guénaël Mettraux.

Known for his hostile approach to the defence and his speculative and leading questions, in the style of a prosecutor, Mettraux, having completed his mission at the Specialist Chambers, is now seeking to become a judge at the International Criminal Court.

In his interview with the ICC, elements stand out that shed light on the way he operates and on the entire Kosovo Specialist Chambers.

In the interview, Mettraux confirmed his deep involvement in drafting the Rules of Procedure and Evidence, one of the key documents governing the internal functioning of the Specialist Court.

In 2017, a panel of the Specialist Court’s Constitutional Court had found at least 13 constitutional violations in these rules, which infringed human rights, thereby requiring the relevant articles to be amended.

In fact, the violation of the human rights of the KLA quartet has been one of the most serious concerns in this trial since 5 November 2020.

Nevertheless, no body within the Specialist Chambers has addressed these concerns with seriousness, responsibility and full impartiality.

And this is due to the way the bodies within the Specialist Chambers function and interact to the detriment of the KLA leaders.

In his interview with the ICC, the Swiss judge confirmed that the panel of judges in the case against the KLA leaders had close and ongoing cooperation with the court’s President, Ekaterina Trendafilova, and the Registrar, Fidelma Donlon.

The report by the Bar Council of England and Wales had raised concerns precisely about the way the actors within the Specialist Chambers cooperated without the defence being involved, thereby creating the impression of a biased process.

Experts had observed frequent interaction between President Trendafilova, the Registrar and the prosecution, including on judicial and administrative matters.

The 2017 decision of the Specialist Chambers’ Constitutional Court called for consultations with all parties, including the defence, in order to guarantee a fair trial.

But this was not respected at all at the Specialist Chambers.

In fact, the defence was fought at every turn and by every political and legal means.

One typical example is the December 2020 meeting between Ekaterina Trendafilova, accompanied by former Chief Prosecutor Jack Smith and Registrar Fidelma Donlon, and European diplomats.

Life sentences for the KLA leaders had been discussed there, the defence had been attacked for seeking their continued detention, and Kosovo’s flag had been seen as a provocation.

Not only had the defence not been invited, but the meeting and discussions were kept secret until they were uncovered through minutes of that meeting.

According to British experts, President Trendafilova’s broad discretion to appoint and dismiss judges was seen as opening the door to further favouritism and manipulation in the process.

The Appeals Chamber is a clear example.

When a judge spoke in favour of releasing Hashim Thaçi from detention, Trendafilova removed him, and thereafter every defence appeal before the Appeals Chamber was unanimously dismissed, while every prosecution appeal was granted.

Therefore, it was hardly surprising that lawyers complained and stood up several times in response to the questions, or that British experts concluded that, through their questions, the judges appeared to be second prosecutors.

Nor were local and international findings that the process was contrived and political at all surprising.

It is therefore hardly surprising that around 90 per cent of Kosovo Albanians consider the judgment unjust, do not want the court to speak on their behalf, and support its abolition.