German judge Kai Ambos, appointed as a member of the Appeals Panel in the case against the KLA leaders in The Hague, had a dark episode with Specialist Court President Ekaterina Trendafilova – when, in an instance in April 2021, he expressed an opinion in favor of the possibility that Hashim Thaçi could be released to defend himself at liberty.
While the panel of which he was himself a member refused to release Thaçi from detention, Ambos had written a separate opinion in which he said that “the existence of a third state that can accept and supervise an accused person may constitute a decisive offer in the context of conditional release”.
In other cases when Thaçi would seek release to defend himself at liberty, according to Ambos, a guarantee from that state itself would be the factor that would shift the balance in favor of conditional release.
And that is what happened. According to the defense documents, just one month later – in June 2021, Thaçi secured guarantees from two NATO states, which promised to keep and supervise the former President throughout the trial, on the condition that he be allowed to defend himself at liberty.
And this is where Court President Ekaterina Trendafilova enters the scene.
In Hashim Thaçi’s next request for release from detention, the Bulgarian judge removed Appeals Judge Kai Ambos from the panel.
In his place, she appointed Italian judge Emilio Gati.
In the end, Thaçi was not released, and the only judge in the entire history of the Specialist Chambers to take the reasonable position that the facts should be properly assessed was excluded.
This case was also addressed in the report containing findings by British lawyers from the renowned BHR organization, who concluded that “Trendafilova’s authority to decide on the composition of panels constituted a concern and a gap in the legal framework”.
And, naturally, questions will arise.
Will the German judge have the strength to once again assess the historical facts fairly?
Or will Ekaterina Trendafilova’s iron hand of influence once again act to the detriment of the KLA?








