As Charles Smith read the summary of the disgraceful verdict against the leaders of the Kosovo Liberation Army, he also referred to Fatmir Limaj as a “war criminal”; Limaj had been acquitted in three court proceedings – in The Hague, by EULEX and by Kosovo’s judiciary.
Limaj sat in the dock of the International Criminal Tribunal in The Hague in February 2003 after being arrested in Slovenia.
Two years later, the Panel of Judges found Limaj not guilty on all counts of the indictment.
“Fatmir Limaj… The Court finds you not guilty on all counts of the indictment,” said Kevin Parker, presiding judge in Limaj’s case, while reading the verdict.
The Hague Prosecutor’s Office appealed the decision in March 2006. Appeal hearings were held in June 2007, and only three months later, in September, the Court once again found Limaj not guilty.
After his case in The Hague concluded, court proceedings against Limaj began in Kosovo.
In July 2011, an EULEX prosecutor in Kosovo filed another indictment against the KLA’s Steel, a case widely known to the public as the Kleçka case.
On 17 September 2013, the Panel of Judges at the Basic Court of Pristina, comprising two EULEX judges and one local judge, found Limaj not guilty on all counts of the indictment.
Following an appeal by former prosecutor Maorizio Salustro, the Basic Court’s decision was appealed. The proceedings dragged on until 14 May 2016, when the Court of Appeals upheld the Basic Court’s acquittal.
The Prosecutor’s Office also took the case to the Supreme Court. A year after the Appeals Court’s decision, on 12 May 2017, the Supreme Court of Kosovo issued its final decision on Limaj – finding him not guilty for the sixth time.
In October 2016, Kosovo’s Special Prosecution Office also filed another indictment against the KLA’s Steel.
This time, he was suspected of war crimes in Bellanicë, Malishevë.
In March 2018, the Basic Court of Gjakova acquitted Limaj. The first-instance decision was also upheld by the Court of Appeals in November of that year.
Three court proceedings and eight acquittals by 26 different judges were not enough for Charls Smith, who on 16 September found Fatmir Limaj guilty of war crimes, even though he had not been charged by the Specialist Prosecutor’s Office.
“Others, and in particular Fatmir Limaj, Sabit Geci, Rrustem Mustafa and Latif Gashi, were zealous implementers of the criminal purpose that targeted opponents,” Smith said while reading the verdict against the former KLA leaders.
This was apparently the decision Smith had wanted to deliver for a long time.
This is confirmed by an email dated 29 January 2013, in which he told the president of the EULEX judges, Malcom Simmons, that “[the Kleçka case] should be scheduled for trial as soon as possible. There are a number of reasons for this… most of them political”.
Indeed, according to Simmons, Smith went even further, saying that the defendants should be convicted because that was what the EULEX mission was expecting…
Limaj was not convicted in The Hague. He was not convicted in the Kleçka case. Nor was he convicted in the Bellanicë case.
But on 16 September 2026, a Court that, beyond its name, is also Special in the way it operates, found Limaj guilty without him having been charged at all.








