The Special Court trial panel, it seems, was not impressed at all by the evidence and documents from the U.S. State Department and the CIA.

And, apparently, more weight was given to rumors from unverified online sites or absurd testimony accusing KLA soldiers of “stealing their cows.”

One of the major scandals at the Specialist Chambers, which occurred in the first months of the trial, before the hearing of testimony and the presentation of documents began, was the concealment of exculpatory evidence.

The Specialist Prosecutor’s Office in The Hague, despite its obligations, kept exculpatory evidence concerning the KLA leaders secret for more than two years.

This involved highly significant evidence, such as a 2000 U.S. CIA report, a 1999 State Department document, and testimony from former OSCE ambassador Daan Everts, which said there was no evidence that the KLA was a structured organization and that, as such, it carried out organized attacks against civilians.

The State Department document, dated May 4, 1999, says that the KLA had no effective command structure.

“Moreover, since there is no political structure in Kosovo or effective command and control of the KLA, it would take many months, if not years, to organize them to use and maintain any military assistance the United States might provide,” the document states.

State Department letter

Meanwhile, in a U.S. intelligence document, the CIA says the KLA was not involved in politically motivated violence.

“The KLA does not appear to be involved in terrorist activities—defined as premeditated, politically motivated violence perpetrated against civilian targets.”

CIA document

Exculpatory evidence is important even at the preliminary stage, because it establishes circumstances for release pending trial, and also serves the proceedings as mitigating evidence at sentencing.

Gregory Kehoe, former lawyer for Hashim Thaçi, had objected to the concealment of these documents on February 4, 2022, during one of the case-status hearings.

“None of this was provided to us when we were exchanging and discussing this evidence. None of this was presented to you, Your Honor. None. And they have had this information for four years, while these four gentlemen have been in prison since November 2020,” he said.

This action by the Prosecutor’s Office undermined not only the trial against the KLA leaders.

“The implications are such that they destroy, shake the foundations of the international justice system,” said Pierre-Richard Prosper, Hashim Thaçi’s lawyer.

By concealing the evidence, the Prosecutor’s Office misled the pretrial judge, starting from the initial phase of the investigations, through the filing of the indictment and its confirmation.

It also violated the accused’s right to the conditional release of the KLA leaders, despite their defense having made dozens of requests.

Defense lawyer for former President Hashim Thaçi, Gregory Kehoe, had also accused the Prosecutor’s Office of concealing the testimony of former OSCE chief Daan Everts.

“The violence after 1999 was not part of a campaign organized by Albanian leaders,” Everts had said in his testimony.