“In the Name of the Father” is an extraordinary film, based on a true story, which tells the story of four Irishmen in the 1970s who were unjustly sentenced to life imprisonment for an attack on two pubs in Guildford, near London.

At the time, the Irish Republican Army was carrying out attacks with the aim of separating Northern Ireland from the United Kingdom.

The trial of Gerry Conlon and his three friends took place under enormous political pressure, and the proceedings were a farce, with evidence fabricated at every level.

The Guildford Four spent 15 years in prison and, in 1989, the Court of Appeal found them innocent.

“Imprisoned for 15 years for something I didn’t do. For something I knew nothing about. A completely innocent man,” Conlon said after his release.

The trial judge convicted them without any physical evidence, compromised impartiality, asked questions like an investigator, considered only the prosecution’s testimony and ignored facts proving their innocence.

There are many similarities with the case against the four KLA members over these six years, particularly in the conduct of the judges.

The scenes in the courtroom in The Hague and the final verdict were an open display of a political, arbitrary and biased trial, with a predetermined judgment.

One of the loyal soldiers in this enterprise that declared the KLA criminal was judge Guénaël Mettraux.

The Swiss judge employed a series of questions and methods that distorted the truth, seeking to find evidence in imagination, speculation and unverified material.

When Sokol Bashota was testifying, Mettraux was paraphrasing some statements by Hashim Thaçi, and when asking a question, misquoted the former president; he did not read the entire paragraph, in order to confuse the witness.

This provoked a fierce reaction from Thaçi.

Mettraux tried to do the same thing again, but the former president reacted once more.

Before that, the Swiss judge was questioning Hajrush Kurtaj and tried several times to elicit evidence from imagination, assumptions and speculation.

Mettraux: “Let’s suppose… perhaps a somewhat speculative question”.

But a guerrilla fighter from Kaçanik taught him a lesson with his answer.

Kurtaj: “As long as I have had no such experience, I cannot speculate or make assumptions”.

Judge Mettraux made his next attempt with witness Kurtesh Fondaj, also a member of the KLA.

His questions forced one of the lawyers to stand up twice to object.

Ellis: “I object to this question. This is a question for the prosecution to ask; the Trial Panel cannot ask this question. This is an entirely leading question. This is not a question for the panel to ask”.

The pressure on Fondaj through investigative-style methods and leading questions was so great that the following day, during his testimony, he asked for a lawyer because he felt he had been mistreated by the judge.

Fondaj: “Yesterday afternoon I watched the recordings presented by the court. I followed them carefully, especially the judge’s questioning; it made me think about asking for a lawyer, or rather, support from a lawyer, because I think I have been mistreated”.

In court proceedings, the parties examine the evidence presented by the prosecution to support its case, and testimony is also taken on the basis of that evidence.

But Mettraux found this easy to bypass and, in one of the hearings, presented documents found online, without any verification.

Judge Mettraux: “I don’t believe there is an ERN number, but you can find it online because it is a public document”.

This conduct by the judges also greatly surprised diplomat James Rubin, who testified for the defense for several days.

Rubin: “To my surprise, the judges asked me questions that seemed extraordinarily biased. They did not sound like questions aimed at establishing the facts”.

In November 2024, in a joint submission, the defense lawyers made it clear to the panel that, through their questions, they were violating human rights and forgetting the basic principle of every trial—the presumption of innocence.

But nothing—not even the basic principles of a fair trial, written down and practiced years earlier in international courts, nor these appeals from the defense and witnesses—stopped this.

A group of British lawyers who monitored the proceedings concluded in their report that these tactics by the judges at the Specialist Chambers effectively make them function as a second prosecutor, thereby undermining the principle of equality of arms.

Gerry Conlon fought a long and difficult battle for justice. But he never gave up.

The citizens of Kosovo, the generation of the war and young people in particular, do not need to be lawyers to recognize bias and the manifestation of injustice.

Therefore, this protest in the square and everywhere is a battle to defeat the constructed judgment through justice. And to show that, anywhere and at any time, the truth cannot be imprisoned.