In the entire guilty verdict against Hashim Thaçi and the others, the panel of judges mentioned only one specific case, by name: the case of Behajdin Allaqi.

“…in the unlawful arrest, detention, transfer and killing of Behajdin Allaqi”…, says Charls Smith.

According to the Trial Panel, Hashim Thaçi and Kadri Veseli took Behajdin Allaqi into custody.

“They took Behajdin Allaqi into custody. Behajdin Allaqi was never seen again, and the Trial Panel is convinced that he was killed,” he continued.

The panel of judges made this finding.

The problem is that no evidence was presented to support the finding and the judges’ conviction.

When a judge makes a finding, the sentence that follows should state the fact on which what was said is based.

Under normal circumstances: the judge should say, “We know this because we have this witness who establishes and confirms it, or we have this document, or we have this evidence.”

For example, the panel found that “Mr. Thaçi and Kadri Veseli… took Behajdin Allaqi into custody.” This is the court’s finding, but the judge does not tell us what evidence it is based on.

So, how was the court convinced that Thaçi and Veseli were guilty of Allaqi’s disappearance and murder?

It never was.

It simply took a collection of hearsay from political opponents and built a thriller-style scenario.

In the ruling that has been published, Judge Charls Smith begins the case concerning Behajdin Allaqi by saying:

“Regarding Behajdin Allaqi, the Trial Panel found that in 1993, Behajdin Allaqi had had a serious disagreement with Hashim Thaçi and Azem Syla,” Smith says.

Do you know where we heard this before?

In Facebook posts like this one by a person named Ibrahim Kelmendi.

Among other things, he wrote:

“in April 1993 and at the Fourth General Meetings of the LPK, held in Prishtina on 26–27 July 1993. It was precisely at the Kollara consultation that the first conflict between Hashim Thaçi and Behajdin Allaqi took place,” his post says.

Here is what the judge says:

“Regarding Behajdin Allaqi, the Trial Panel found that in 1993, Behajdin Allaqi had had a serious disagreement with Hashim Thaçi and Azem Syla.”

The truth about the situation is completely different.

This is also borne out by one of Behadin Allaqi’s own friends, Ali Ahmeti.

“There was no clash at all between Hashim Thaçi and Behajdin Allaqi in Kollare,” Ali Ahmeti says.

So the clash between Thaçi and Allaqi in 1993 never happened. It was merely a story fabricated many years later by political opponents for the needs of the time.

The rest of the judge’s sentences are likewise a mechanical echo of articles in Bota Sot.

For example, here is an article titled:

“Thaçi and Kadri Veseli killed Behajdin Allaqi and Shaban Shala, then disappeared them.”

Here is what the judge says:

“Thaçi and Kadri Veseli. They took Behajdin Allaqi into custody. Behajdin Allaqi was never seen again, and the Trial Panel is convinced that he was killed.”

The same applies to other passages.

The judge speaks as political opponents used to speak, as in this video of Liburn Aliu in the Assembly of Kosovo.

“The most sensitive issue of our entire war is the case of Behajdin Allaqi. You all know what I am talking about, and Hashim Thaçi knows it most specifically and best,” Aliu said in 2013.

In statements like these, we see an imaginary narrative move from a conspiracy newspaper to institutionalization when it is also mentioned in the Assembly of Kosovo by a politician.

The point is that, once again, nothing concrete is provided here.

“He knows,” and “this one knows” are phrases that say nothing, but create the desired suspicion.

And then it continues.

“The Deputy Prime Minister is the last person who was with Behajdin Allaqi, but he does not say what happened to him,” Albin Kurti said in 2016.

Now, a few questions that Albin Kurti and Liburn Aliu should answer.

From whom, and where, did they get the information that Behajdin Allaqi was last seen with Hashim Thaçi?

Who told them this, which they are now passing on to the citizens?

How is it possible to make accusations of murder in parliament without any need to present facts and evidence?

But this is not the strangest part of Albin Kurti’s statement in Parliament.

He says something else, which the court repeated word for word when it convicted the KLA leaders.

Albin Kurti says in his speech:

“As an intellectual, political and national leader, Behajdin Allaqi came immediately after Ukshin Hoti, and it is known that such leaders guide the war. Thaçi owes his rise in his career precisely to his betrayals and concessions,” Kurti continued.

So Albin Kurti holds Hashim Thaçi accountable for Allaqi, because according to Kurti, Thaçi was not only the last person seen with him, but also benefited politically from Allaqi’s murder.

And what did the judge say?

“This resulted in Mr. Thaçi taking on the role that had been promised to Behajdin Allaqi,” Smith said.

What Albin Kurti and Charls Smith have in common here is not only the identical finding that makes Thaçi guilty of a murder committed for political gain, but also the fact that neither Kurti nor Smith provides evidence.

They do not say where the information is verified, and they do not bother to provide evidence.

Another interesting point of convergence between Albin Kurti and the Special Prosecutor’s Office also came in 2023.

In 2023, Albin Kurti unexpectedly commemorated on his Facebook page a person he had never commemorated before.

Never at any other time, only in 2023.

Kurti commemorated Behajdin Allaqi.

“Behajdin Allaqi was disappeared,” Albin Kurti wrote, confidently, perhaps also informed that his case was included in the indictment brought by the Special Prosecutor’s Office.

The idea here was to make the Allaqi case better known to people, to talk about it more, so that when the Special Prosecutor’s Office accused the KLA leaders in The Hague over it, the citizens of Kosovo would have a better understanding of what it was about.

Because, of all the cases mentioned in the verdict, this was the only one the Prosecution referred to by name: the case of Behajdin Allaqi.

WHY?

To destroy Thaçi and Veseli’s reputations, of course.

To sow the necessary resentment against them, so that when the draconian sentences came, they would be met not with outrage, but with silence.

That this was a plan became clear from the defense’s response, too.

Hashim Thaçi’s lawyer, Luka Misetic, revealed that during the proceedings in The Hague, the court had ordered them not to speak publicly about the Allaqi case.

Not to mention it at all during the proceedings.

Yet the court itself mentioned it in the ruling.

Therefore, Hashim Thaçi has asked, through his lawyer, for all the findings and evidence on which the prosecution based its decision to be made public.

There is evidence, but it points to the opposite, and has existed for a long time.

Behadin Allaqi’s own wife, Nazmije Allaqi, testified as early as 21 November 2000 that “her husband had disappeared and had been taken by Serbian forces in the village of Drenoc.”

Behadin Allaqi remains missing, but there are now two questions about his case that can no longer be made to disappear.

How did it happen that a court in the heart of European justice convicted someone of murder without evidence, and how did Albin Kurti—the man who once criticized the establishment of the court because of the political compromise—become the man who supplied the narrative for the court’s political sentencing?