More serious and wrong than repairing Kosovo’s railcars in Serbia, just a few months after Serbia attempted to annex part of Kosovo, may be Artane Rizvanolli’s justification.

“Trainkos did not select the subcontractor in Serbia. In fact, under the current Public Procurement Law, a public enterprise cannot intervene in the selection of subcontractors. The private operator that won the tender stated that only the selected subcontractor could repair the railcars.”

In a matter of seconds, a pile of falsehoods, hypocrisies, but also valuable material for the prosecution regarding the €423,000 tender. 

With immense arrogance, Rizvanolli is saying that the state of Kosovo, a few months after the terrorist attack in Banjska, in which a Kosovo police officer was killed and the constitutional order was violated, apparently had neither the ability nor the right to cancel a tender in which the contractor and main beneficiary was Serbia and its companies.

How could the state of Kosovo, so easily, five months after terrorists from Serbia entered Kosovo in pickup trucks carrying weapons, entrust the repair of five railcars, property of the state and serving its citizens, to a company in Serbia?

In the state that, 27 years ago, expelled nearly 1 million citizens, using train wagons as well.

Has the Government ever taken an interest, asked or investigated whether the Serbian company Sinvoz has done work or provided services for the Serbian army? 

It is absurd to hear a minister-MP who apparently does not know and, strangely enough, has not even investigated who else in the region—Croatia or Slovenia, for example—repairs railcars, while she eagerly rejects American gas and presents herself as if she knows a great deal about where that gas comes from, how much it costs, whether it is economical, and who is behind it.

It is laughable when Rizvanolli speaks of institutional independence and non-interference, when she was happy to interfere in the hiring procedures for the CEO at Ibër-Lepenc.

In fact, it is quite clear that this repair process did not go ahead out of naivety, nor because of procedural impossibility or compliance with the law.

TrainKos and the Government knew from the outset that the repairs would take place in Serbia. And this would be done illegally.

In the Procurement Law, the Public Procurement Regulation, the notice announcing the opening of the tender for repairs, dated February 15, 2024, and the contract between TrainKos and Profitech, one of the mandatory criteria is that the bidder must declare the subcontractor, the work it will carry out, and the location of the workshop.

Moreover, the contract between TrainKos and Profitech states that any subcontracting must be approved by the contracting authority—in this case, the TrainKos enterprise.

If the tender-winning company, Profitech sh.p.k., declared Sinvoz, a company from Zrenjanin, Serbia, as its subcontractor when it applied, the Kosovo authorities knew about and approved the repairs in Serbia and, despite the circumstances at the time, shamelessly did nothing, but approved them behind the public’s back.

But here it appears that things took a different and illegal course in several respects.

The contract between TrainKos and Profitech does not mention the subcontractor anywhere—in this case, Sinvoz from Zrenjanin—even though this was a mandatory criterion.

The Public Procurement Regulation prohibits subcontracting during the execution of a contract.

If the winning company did not declare its subcontractor, but secured one only after the tender, how was this allowed?

The minister’s statements indicate that the main contractor, in reality responsible for almost 100% of the work, was Sinvoz in Serbia.

Pay attention here, because this is illegal.

The Procurement Regulation clearly specifies that the subcontractor may not exceed 40% of the contract value, the work, and the financial resources.

While this whole affair was unfolding behind closed doors, the Government was entrusting the railcars to Serbia and paying it for the service, while populist rhetoric was being disseminated in public, calling on the West to sanction Serbia.

In this whole pile of lies and hypocrisies, there are several undeniable truths.

The state knew about and approved the repairs in Serbia, five months after the brutal aggression in the north.

And it did so using illegal methods and procedures.

If repairing some railcars in 2024 was more important to this government than state dignity, then today it is essential and dignified for the prosecution to investigate and repair this entire process—if it is independent, of course.