In Kosovo, free and critical thought has begun to turn into a crime, and for this you are punished and monitored by the government through bodies that serve as Thought Police, just as in George Orwell’s novel 1984.
If you have not experienced it personally, there are individuals who have been punished by the Vetëvendosje government simply for speaking critically, without accusing, insulting or slandering anyone.
A few weeks ago, archaeologist Shafi Gashi, who works at the Kosovo Archaeological Institute, an institution under the Ministry of Culture, was punished with a 30% salary cut for 3 months, simply for expressing criticism in the media about the lack of investment in Prizren Castle and the closure of part of it to visitors.
A Disciplinary Commission was established for the archaeologist, who has dozens of scientific publications and has led dozens of archaeological excavations across Kosovo, and its members justified the punishment on the grounds that Gashi “spoke without prior permission from the hierarchy.”
This, before being laughable, is in fact frightening.
Being punished for speaking and for thinking differently is the logic of authoritarian states.
Two renowned international historians, Oliver Schmidt and Konrad Clewing, who have studied Kosovo’s history in depth, also called the Ministry of Culture’s action authoritarian.
According to them, such cases are common in countries with an authoritarian political culture. Reacting to Gashi’s case, they also mention a case in Romania, where archaeologist Ioan Piso was removed from his position as director of the country’s most important archaeological site after leading a protest against a gold mine, which had angered politically influential circles.
When the Ministry of Culture invokes respect for the hierarchy, also citing the Law on Public Officials, to punish archaeologist Gashi, would it act the same way if he expressed praise for this government without first obtaining permission from the hierarchy?
Of course not.
The six-year history of this government has shown that those who have obeyed it and fawned on it excessively, those who have sharpened their tongues to curse, accuse and bully journalists and critics of the government, have only been promoted and made comfortable in institutions, whether in political posts or in the administration.
This Thought Police in Kosovo does not punish only those who work in the state administration. It also organizes exclusions, punishments and labeling of free citizens, young people with ambition and a desire to get involved.
On August 12, Olsa Sadiku happened to be in the Kosovo Assembly hall as a visitor, when Vetëvendosje and Democratic Party of Kosovo MPs were clashing over the call to convene the session.
As the confrontation was beginning, she expressed an opinion about the political situation in Kosovo:
“Well, yes, we haven’t had a government for two years, so why let it continue?” she said.
This completely spontaneous opinion came at a cost.
Olsa is from Obiliq and, as a young woman, had begun an initiative to establish a branch of the Kosovo Youth Assembly in her municipality.
The Youth Assembly, which is merely a non-governmental organization, decided to end its cooperation with Olsa simply because she expressed an opinion in the Assembly hall.
The experiences of archaeologist Gashi and Olsa are by no means isolated cases.
They are symptoms of a dangerous governing mindset.
And they bring to mind the experiment with the frog.
When you throw it into hot water, it jumps out immediately. But if you put it in cold water and heat the water gradually, the frog gets used to the temperature little by little, until it fails to realize that the water has become dangerous.
That is why restrictions on free thought do not always come in the form of a sweeping ban. They come in the form of a punishment, an exclusion, a label, pressure, a “prior permission” to speak.
If you get used to each of them, one day you may discover that the water has become so hot and dangerous that you no longer have the strength to jump out.








