Guénaël Mettraux: Mr. Emmerson, as to your wording, there is no secret trial here.
Ben Emmerson: Well, with all due respect, that is a matter of opinion.
Guénaël Mettraux: There is a trial, Mr. Emmerson, that we all want to be more public than it has been, and that is why we are holding this hearing. There is no secret that the information –
Ben Emmerson: I appreciate that the terminology is unattractive, but this is my terminology. This is how I would describe these proceedings.
This confrontation between Ben Emmerson, former lawyer for Kadri Veseli, and the Swiss judge—not particularly friendly toward the defense, Genaul Métreaux—took place almost three months after witness hearings had begun.
The trial judging the entire Kosovo Liberation Army, criminalizing it even in its objectives, the trial attempting to rewrite the story of Kosovo’s freedom and independence, was proceeding in deep darkness for the public.
Emmerson:
“We are sliding toward a secret trial”.
Three years later, when the courtroom was closed to make way for the drafting of the verdict, Emmerson’s warning proved to be very accurate.
The trial of Hashim Thaçi, Kadri Veseli, Jakup Krasniqi and Rexhep Selimi was a secret trial.
The verdict to be handed down on September 16 will be based on proceedings that shut the door on the public.
Of around 270 witnesses, 138 testimonies were submitted in writing—of which the public knows absolutely nothing. Around 70 witnesses appeared in closed sessions. Only about 50 others were heard in public.
In the face of these figures, the Prosecution is still trying to muddy the waters.
Angela Griep, spokesperson for the Specialist Chambers:
“Court hearings at the KSC are public, except in exceptional circumstances”.
When the courtroom echoed with calls for open proceedings, the prosecution justified itself with claims of witness intimidation.
But at one point, it was put on the spot, and its narrative proved inaccurate.
Judge Smith: Any information on where an intimidation took place?
Prosecutor Quick: Your Honour, I do not think I can discuss individual incidents or cases.
Judge Smith: What do you mean?
Prosecutor Quick: I do not think I can discuss individual incidents or cases.
Judge Smith: I am not asking you to discuss individuals. I am asking you, do you have any?
Prosecutor Quick: Your Honour, we do not.
In democratic countries, a public trial is a universal principle of justice and a fundamental right of the accused.
Strangely, this was not applied at the Specialist Chambers.
With the hearings closed, the citizens of Kosovo have been deprived of the opportunity to understand the truthfulness of the evidence, the credibility of the witnesses, the methods of the prosecutors, the judges’ positions and the arguments of the defense teams.
And the question rightly arises: how the hell will that decision be written and delivered in the name of the people?
Ben Emmerson
“How in God’s name are you going to write a judgment that makes sense of the evidence heard in closed session”.
So, can you legitimize a judicial process that slammed the doors on the public and trampled on the universal principles of justice?
Luka Misetic
“Reviewing the SPO’s closing submissions is like reading a movie review written by someone who has not seen the movie.”
The six years of the largest trial concerning Kosovo’s war for freedom have clearly shown that the Specialist Court closed its doors because it feared that an open trial would reveal the extreme weakness of the evidence, its dubious origins, and the exaggeration of the case through hearsay and deliberate misrepresentations.
When the judges draft their decision, based on 5,400 pieces of evidence and more than 29,000 pages of hearing transcripts, many of them redacted from the public, they will not decide only on Thaçi, Veseli, Krasniqi and Selimi.
They will decide whether the history of Kosovo’s freedom in alliance with the West will be rewritten by a secret and political trial, marked by numerous deviations and major question marks.








