The Court of Appeals of the Specialist Chambers has once again ruled in favor of the Prosecution in the case against Hashim Thaçi and others on charges of attempting to obstruct justice.
The Single Judge in the case had decided months earlier not to admit the testimony and report of a prosecution witness, referred to in filings as Witness 8.
This was because the witness had refused to provide details about the work methodology and the findings in the report.
The Single Judge had initially deferred the decision on the expert’s admissibility until after hearing his testimony, which took place on 3 and 4 March 2026.
On 27 March 2026, following additional submissions by the parties, the judge decided not to admit the expert report, its accompanying materials, or the related testimony.
In an appeal filed on 11 May 2026, the Prosecution argued that the Single Trial Judge “erred in law and abused his discretion in interpreting and applying the relevant provisions, which led to the exclusion of Witness 8’s evidence”.
On 21 May 2026, the Defence sought dismissal of the appeal, saying that the first-instance decision was based on several independent and sufficient grounds for exclusion.
Having assessed the parties’ arguments, the Panel found that some of the grounds of the Prosecution’s appeal were well-founded and that the first-instance assessment required reconsideration.
Consequently, the Court of Appeals has partially granted the SPO’s appeal and ordered the matter returned to the Single Judge to reassess the admissibility of Witness 8’s report and the relevant materials.









