Andy Burnham’s arrival as prime minister of Britain is “the most significant moment of change in our politics in 40 years” — at least according to Burnham himself. Entering 10 Downing Street on July 20, he declared: “Let’s make this the moment when Britain starts believing again.”

However, the forceful rhetoric has not been accompanied by a transformative vision for government. Sixteen years after first attempting to become leader of the Labour Party and a year after seriously beginning preparations for the new role, Burnham has got to work without much momentum. He explains well what he opposes, but offers much less clarity about what he intends to do as prime minister.

The prime minister’s first task was a cabinet purge: he sacked all of his predecessor Sir Keir Starmer’s closest allies, including Starmer’s Chancellor of the Exchequer, Rachel Reeves. Among those removed were most of the people who had shaped Starmer’s economic approach, which — at least in rhetoric, if not always in practice — favoured technology, deregulation and a focus on housebuilding, with the aim of stimulating Britain’s sluggish economic growth. Peter Kyle, Steve Reed, Liz Kendall and Darren Jones were removed from their respective posts overseeing business, housing, science and the running of government. Burnham’s determination to erase his predecessor’s economic legacy aligns with his recent attacks on 40 years of “neoliberalism”.

However, the new Chancellor of the Exchequer, John Healey, does not represent a complete break with the past. He served for five years as a minister in the Treasury under Sir Tony Blair’s government. His appointment, which surprised most observers, does not necessarily signal a radical departure from economic orthodoxy. What it does show, however, is that the prime minister is willing to spend much more on defence. Healey resigned as Starmer’s Defence Secretary in June after a funding dispute. Will he now manage to secure the additional billions for military investment that the Treasury had previously denied?

Ed Miliband, who was tipped as a candidate for the post of Chancellor of the Exchequer, becomes Foreign Secretary, while another contender, Shabana Mahmood, remains Home Secretary — a sign that Burnham supports her tough approach to both legal and illegal immigration.

Healey’s first task will be to approve a package of measures aimed at helping Britons cope with the cost of living. He will also have to find the funds to fulfil the prime minister’s first concrete promise: “ending rough sleeping” — a project Burnham had also attempted as mayor of Greater Manchester, but with limited success.

On foreign policy, the prime minister showed that he understands where his priorities should lie through his first three calls with foreign leaders: he spoke with Donald Trump, Volodymyr Zelensky and Ursula von der Leyen, president of the European Commission. However, Miliband’s selection to lead the Foreign Office means the frequent turnover of ministers continues. Britain has now had seven different foreign secretaries in the past five years — damning evidence of the country’s political turmoil and of successive leaders’ inability to set a direction and stick to it.

Worryingly, for a man who declared that he was “ready”, Burnham has signalled that some of his biggest decisions will be postponed even further. He has promised to present a “ten-year plan” sometime in the autumn. It is likely that this plan will also include his solution to the complex problem of reforming social care for older people.

His greatest political passion is devolving power from Westminster to England’s regions, but here too he has offered very few concrete details. Britain’s problems are too urgent for its leaders to keep wasting time.

Despite the slow start, there are reasons to be optimistic about the new prime minister. His ability to keep cabinet appointments almost entirely secret until they are announced stands in stark contrast to recent governments. If he has shown the same level of discipline in his policy programme, then it is possible that a coherent set of ideas will emerge in the coming weeks, with the ten-year plan serving as a coherent culmination rather than an attempt to start everything from scratch.

His central message to the country from the steps of 10 Downing Street, that Britons need to rediscover “their shared purpose”, is the right one.

However, there remains a troubling possibility that his political thinking is indeed as poor as it seems and that Burnham’s government will end up being merely a version of Starmer’s government, but with a northern accent.

An even worse scenario is also possible. He has refused to rule out some bad economic ideas, such as rent controls and the mass nationalisation of public services, measures that would weaken growth and further destabilise already fragile public finances.

For now, and despite Burnham’s three decades in public life, Britons still know remarkably little about the intentions of their new prime minister.