The scenes from the World Cup occasionally brought to mind another era of global politics and another America. Scottish football fans somehow managed to leave Boston without beer. Bewildered Europeans marvelled on TikTok at Texas’s giant portions. Americans watched in amazement as Japanese fans cleaned the stadiums after matches. The streets were dominated by festivals celebrating differences and shared joy.
Meanwhile, the US government continued its policy of random acts of cruelty: it barred a Somali referee from entering the country and forced Iranian players to leave the country immediately after their matches. The latest controversy concerned US authorities disregarding or circumventing the rules to overturn the red card shown to a player on the US national team.
The tournament loudly revealed a reality the world had quietly understood since the start of Donald Trump’s second term: Americans are one thing; America is something else entirely.
In Canada, when the United States turned from a partner into a threat, it sparked an outburst of nationalism not seen since the 1960s.
“First of all, it’s stupid to hate all Americans,” said writer Margaret Atwood, who had lived through that nationalism. “You can dislike the administration without saying that all Americans are bad people.”
At a time when Canadian citizens were turning American products around in supermarkets so other shoppers would avoid them, this was remarkably valuable advice.
It has been surprisingly easy to follow that advice. Washington’s searing madness, in its latest phase of decadence, is a disaster that primarily affects Americans themselves. It’s not just that Trump’s approval rating has fallen below 40 per cent. Americans’ pride in their country is also in steady decline. Trust in national institutions has collapsed. Even the idea of “American exceptionalism” is fading.
According to one poll, only 22 per cent of Americans under the age of 30 believe that the “American dream” still exists. Americans feel disconnected from their own country.
On July 4, white nationalists travelled in disguise on the Washington Metro. African American passengers were forced to share the train with them. During a severe storm, MAGA supporters attending the Great American State Affair took shelter in the National Museum of African American History and Culture. Choose your own symbol of division; both scenes describe the state of America today.
Canada has distanced itself from the US in many areas since the start of Trump’s second term: tourism, trade, military procurement and more. Yet anti-Americanism is not the same as it was in the 1960s or during George W. Bush’s second administration, because nobody blames ordinary American citizens for the war with Iran, ICE or the threats against Greenland.
The United States is becoming a country where the government’s actions must be separated from the will of the people.
The Trump administration’s attempt to impose American digital services on Canada and Europe has made clear that American technology and finance companies are no longer neutral service providers, but agents of American authoritarianism—or at least could become so.
Democratic backsliding over the past two years has taken many forms: concentrating power in the executive branch, weakening the Voting Rights Act and gerrymandering electoral boundaries. In the 2026 midterm elections, only 18 seats in the House of Representatives are considered genuinely competitive. The US Congress is no longer an institution with real political competition.
It would be just as absurd to blame Turks for the actions of Erdogan’s government as it would be to blame Americans for the actions of the US government.
Nevertheless, the global rejection of all things American is almost inevitable. Any American product or service connected to the US government or subject to US laws poses a threat to the sovereignty of other democracies.
For Canadians, not travelling to the US began as a boycott, but now it is more a way of protecting themselves. The US government has made it clear that foreigners on its territory may be treated as potential enemies. Would you go to Disneyland if there were a chance you’d first be subjected to a humiliating body search?
The reason America is now seen as a greater threat than China or Russia in many parts of the world is not that it is necessarily worse, but that it is unpredictable. The military gets involved in killings for the leader’s amusement. It starts wars without a plan. No one knows anymore what a deal with the US government is worth. No one is sure whether negotiators have the authority or whether they will keep their word.
It’s easy not to be anti-American, because there is no longer an America united enough to hate.
From the outside, America looks like a house where domestic violence takes place. Inside, some try to appease the abuser. Some flee. Some fight. Others try to ignore everything. Some just pretend. When you’re a neighbour, all you need to do is make sure you’ve locked the door.
The same polls that showed Americans’ declining trust in their country also showed that “Americans, by an overwhelming majority, want a country that embraces pluralism at home and behaves like a good neighbour on the international stage.”
But you don’t need polls to know this. You only need to know a few Americans. Their system is not allowing them to have the country they want and deserve.
Canadians understand better than anyone that the decline of the US is not happening because Americans are bad people. They are our friends, family and colleagues. The problem is that their systems are collapsing.
That is why rejecting American systems—in defence, technology, the economy, culture and other areas—is becoming even more important.
The beer sellers in Boston and the grill masters in Texas are not the same as ICE agents. They have almost nothing to do with one another. That is precisely the problem.
Folarin Balogun’s red card being overturned is not his fault. Nevertheless, the US national team’s performance will now carry a footnote.
Today, in every respect, America too has a footnote next to its name.









