Many historians have recently viewed the American Revolution as a moderate, even disappointing, event. But in the era of Donald Trump, the old question of how radical it was is taking on new significance.
The Declaration of Independence turned 250 this Fourth of July, with patriotic celebrations befitting the anniversary of the world’s longest-lasting democracy. Yet the founding narrative on which it rests is becoming increasingly contentious.
Conservatives have accused progressives of abandoning the wisdom of the Declaration of Independence and distorting the legacy of the American Revolution. On the other hand, on the left, some believe that the narrative of freedom, which once inspired peoples around the world, is losing its influence as its hypocrisies and contradictions have been exposed.
Among scholars, the 50 years since the 1976 bicentennial have significantly broadened the way the Revolution is viewed. New figures have been included, and the geographical scope and chronology of events have expanded, turning what was once considered a unified national story into a far more complicated, fragmented narrative connected to a wider global conflict.
But in both academic studies and the polarized public debate around 1776, an old question remains: How revolutionary was the American Revolution really?
For many Americans, this question may seem strange. The very name “American Revolution” implies its revolutionary character, while the celebration of the 250th anniversary seems like proof of it.
Nevertheless, this is an issue being debated in practice as well. The patriotic version of 1776 promoted by President Donald Trump has been met with the self-conscious use of Revolutionary-era symbolism during the “No Kings” protests.
Historian T.H. Breen of Northwestern University called this an important, if “somewhat awkward,” question.
“If we hadn’t had the Revolution, maybe we’d look like Canada,” he said. “Canada is a democracy, too. But we had the Revolution. So we want to understand: in what way was it really a revolution?”
A conservative revolution?
Americans have debated the history and meaning of the Revolution almost since the moment it ended. In the 19th century, its legacy was claimed both by abolitionists and the women’s suffrage movement, who embraced the Declaration’s promise of equality, and by Southerners, who saw themselves as rebels against an oppressive power.
The patriotic narrative known today took shape in the early 20th century, when American leaders sought to strengthen the federal government while also countering new revolutionary waves coming from Europe.
In 1926, during his speech marking the 150th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, President Calvin Coolidge described the Revolution as “a movement of the people,” but “in no sense a radical movement.” In his view, the vision set forth in the Declaration was perfect and needed no changes.
“If all men are created equal, that is final,” he said. “If they are endowed with inalienable rights, that is final. If governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed, that is final.”
It was presented as a struggle for individual rights and the free-market economy. Conservatives argued that it was undoubtedly a revolution, but not a Russian- or French-style revolution.
In a 1973 essay titled “The American Revolution as a Successful Revolution,” neoconservative political theorist Irving Kristol criticized left-wing scholars who downplayed its significance, describing it as “a French Revolution that never quite happened.”
Unlike in Russia or France, he wrote, the passions of the American revolutionaries were restrained by reason and virtue.
“The American Revolution was successful because those who led it were able, years later, to look calmly at what they had built and say that it was a good thing,” Kristol wrote.
Unlike the leaders of other revolutions, which ended up consuming themselves, they “all died in their beds.”
Among historians, a growing interest in the revolutionaries’ ideology was gaining ground, developed in books such as Bernard Bailyn’s classic study, “The Ideological Origins of the American Revolution,” published in 1967.
But at the same time, amid the social upheavals of the 1960s and 1970s, social history, which focused on ordinary people, began to dominate the academic world. Scholars began to explore the perspectives of women, free and enslaved African Americans, Native Americans, and the working class.
During the Revolution’s bicentennial, a New York Times reporter interviewed prominent historians and noticed a deep divide between the older generation, which emphasized the founders’ political ideas, and younger historians, who advocated what was called “history from below.”
For the latter, the Revolution was initially an explosion of popular democratic impulses, which were later suppressed by the elites.
Since then, scholars have continued to broaden the Revolution’s geographical perspective, placing it within a much larger global war involving several empires.
The history is no longer limited to debates in Philadelphia or Boston. It also includes Native Americans in the Ohio Valley, naval battles along the Gulf of Mexico, slave uprisings in Jamaica, and even trade in India.
Scholars today also focus more on the consequences than on the causes of the Revolution. These consequences were by no means equal for everyone.
As historian Michael D. Hattem has put it, the result is an American Revolution “that looks less and less American and less and less revolutionary.”
“During the Cold War, the question was: ‘Was it a revolution?’ Today the question is: ‘Whose revolution was it?’” said Hattem, author of “The Memory of ’76,” which examines how the American Revolution has been remembered.
Nevertheless, some of the best-known figures in the field continued to interpret the Revolution in much more positive terms.
In his Pulitzer Prize-winning book, “The Radicalism of the American Revolution” (1991), historian Gordon S. Wood argues that the Revolution brought about more than a new form of government. It also created a culture far more egalitarian and individualistic than the Founding Fathers themselves had imagined.
Today, however, many historians of the younger generation see the Revolution as an event that had deeply conservative consequences, especially on the issues of slavery and race.
After the Revolution, the Northern states began to abolish slavery, while enslaved people used the ideas of the Declaration of Independence to demand their freedom.
But in the South, slavery not only survived, but was strengthened and expanded westward.
For Native Americans, meanwhile, the westward expansion spurred by the Revolution proved catastrophic.
“Yes, some truly radical processes were set in motion,” said historian Leslie M. Harris, a specialist in early African American history at Northwestern University. “But you can’t ignore the deeply conservative limits of that radicalism.”
Harris, echoing the argument of many other historians, says the American Revolution looks much more revolutionary when viewed as the spark that ignited an “Age of Revolutions” throughout the Atlantic world. It influenced not only France, but also Haiti, Venezuela, Ireland, Poland, and many other places.
“The Revolution really created a new way of thinking, not just about slavery, but about humanity itself,” Harris said. “It posed the question: ‘What is freedom?’”
Yale historian Joanne B. Freeman has taught a popular course on the American Revolution for nearly 30 years.
In an interview, she said that today the Revolution may not seem very radical, at least in its immediate consequences. But as it unfolded, people experienced it as something they had to take part in.
“It affected people in ways they perhaps hadn’t expected,” she said. “Not necessarily as some grand ideological issue. But suddenly, they felt they had to do something, write something, protest.”
It has become common for many liberals and progressives to downplay the significance of the American Revolution and see the country’s “Second Founding,” after the Civil War, as a more suitable starting point for America’s multiethnic democracy.
But historian David Waldstreicher, a specialist in early American history at the Graduate Center of the City University of New York, says this approach underestimates the Revolution’s impact in politicizing ordinary people, and not just white men.
“That politicization is the foundation of American democracy,” he said.
From Revolution to the Founding
Since the Revolution’s bicentennial, the American right has increasingly dominated public memory of the American Revolution, embracing a legal and historical interpretation based on the original text of the founding documents.
In recent years, however, divisions have begun to emerge within the right as well.
Some nationalist conservatives have rejected the universalism of the Declaration of Independence, arguing that the United States is the homeland of a particular people and culture, rather than a nation built on a universal civic creed.
Other conservatives, who support the concept of the “common good,” argue that the Declaration’s emphasis on individual rights weakens the bond between God and society.
Nevertheless, the 1776 version promoted by the Trump administration remains very close to the traditional heroic narrative, centered on leading figures.
Freedom Trucks, a fleet of mobile history museums funded by the federal government for the 250th anniversary in partnership with Hillsdale College and conservative platform PragerU, welcome visitors with an AI-generated video of George Washington.
The Revolution is presented as a series of heroic events – Lexington, Concord, Bunker Hill – stemming from the truths proclaimed in the Declaration of Independence.
The exhibits mention slavery, but describe the Founding Fathers as a group of people who were essentially opposed to it and who “foresaw that slavery would gradually fade and disappear over time.”
These exhibits have been criticized by historians, who believe they present a sanitized version of history.
Nevertheless, Matthew Spalding, a constitutional scholar and head of Hillsdale College’s Washington operations, who helped create the exhibit, said these criticisms stem from a “postmodern” approach to history, which imposes the values of the present on the past.
According to Spalding, what made the American Revolution revolutionary – even radical – was its deliberate, rational character and the fact that it proclaimed the birth of a new nation founded on truths considered self-evident, beginning with the principle that “all men are created equal.”
“Part of the problem is that we want to see it as revolutionary immediately, in the modern sense of the word,” he said. “But the American Revolution established the principle, planted the seed, and then it developed throughout American history.”
Yuval Levin, a constitutional scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, a conservative think tank that was not part of the project, also agrees that the American Revolution was a “conservative revolution.”
“It was more or less the first successful colonial rebellion in the known history of the world,” he said in an email response, “but it advanced by insisting on the ideals of the mother country more than by breaking away from them.”
According to Levin, slavery was a “moral stain” in which the Founding Fathers were also complicit.
Nevertheless, he argues that slavery was abolished precisely by demanding that the United States live up to the ideals on which it was founded, and not by overthrowing them.
“I don’t think the Founding Fathers, on the whole, were early opponents of slavery,” he said. “But the logic of the Revolution pointed in that direction.”
The history of the American Revolution continues to be rewritten, and there will never be a definitive version.
Historian T.H. Breen of Northwestern University says scholars’ task is “to do the best they can with the evidence that has survived, in the hope that it will help Americans think honestly and critically about their origins.”
According to Breen, the Revolution belonged to the people. And, as other historians also point out, its legacy belongs to people today, at a time when Americans – as in 1776 – may not need either leaders or historians to explain its meaning to them.
“Everyone knows that the American Revolution was against monarchy,” said historian David Waldstreicher. “Nobody needed to open a book to go out to the ‘No Kings’ protests.”









