Trendafilova: “The judges of the Specialist Chambers have never been subject to influence or interference from outside in the performance of their duties”.
When, in April 2021, the panel of judges at the Court of Appeals, composed of Michèle Picard, Kai Ambos and Nina Jørgensen, rejected the release from detention of former president Hashim Thaçi, one of the three had a different view from his colleagues.
Judge Kai Ambos expressed separately and publicly the opinion that a third state’s willingness to accept and supervise a suspect or accused person could constitute an important, perhaps decisive, offer in the context of conditional release.
German judge Ambos’s act did not easily escape Ekaterina Trendafilova’s clutches.
Ambos was immediately removed from the panel at the Court of Appeals and replaced by another judge, Emilio Gatti, after which the decisions in other motions would prove unanimous against the defense.
With this, Trendafilova testified that the entire chain at the Specialist Chambers is dependent on and influenced from within, by Trendafilova’s hand, while she herself is caught from within and by politics and diplomacy from outside.
The defense had characterized this act by Trendafilova as a violation of the law, a brutal interference in the judges’ independence, and a violation of the accused’s rights to a fair and independent trial.
Thaçi’s lawyers requested that Judge Emilio Gatti be removed and that the decision on a different panel be made by the court’s vice-president, not Trendafilova again.
This effort was futile, because Trendafilova’s iron hand overturned every defense request and everything would continue to go as she wanted.
That Ekaterina Trendafilova was influenced from within by Jack Smith and from outside by European politics and diplomacy, and that she then influenced the judges, is also demonstrated by a meeting in December 2020 between Trendafilova and Prosecutor Jack Smith with European Union ambassadors.
This meeting, which would not be the Specialist Chambers’ only briefing to European bureaucracy, also showed that for as long as he served at the Specialist Chambers, former prosecutor Jack Smith completely directed President Trendafilova.
In minutes of that meeting, published for the first time by VOX Kosova, Trendafilova was asked about the moment when Thaçi’s lawyer had asked in the courtroom why there was no Kosovo flag.
The lawyer’s statement: “Why is there no Kosovo flag if this is a court of Kosovo?”
Trendafilova would call this question a provocation of the judge, intended to create a political debate.
Imagine that—the Kosovo flag constitutes a provocation.
And here, in the minutes, she shows that she strongly influences the judges’ conduct, even though this is prohibited by the Specialist Court’s own rules of procedure.
“The previous judge was polite and respectful to him, something that will not happen in other cases if it is raised again,” Trendafilova said at the meeting.
If judges are independent in their work, how did Trendafilova know how the judge would act in the future?
Why should she tell the judge not to behave well toward the lawyer in the future?
And why should she make statements about how the judge should act in the presence of European diplomats and former chief prosecutor Jack Smith, who was one of the parties in the proceedings, not a member of Trendafilova’s office?
At this meeting, she showed that her relations with former chief prosecutor Jack Smith were extremely close and that, in a way, she was being directed by him.
There, Trendafilova was discussing the fate of the four leaders of the Kosovo Liberation Army with political representatives of European countries.
The president of the Specialist Chambers tells the ambassadors that Jack Smith had told her he “would present the reasons why Thaçi should not be released from detention”.
Terrible.
First, the prosecutor is only a party to a proceeding, just like the defense, so why should only he be at that meeting? Why was the defense not present too, as the other party?
But most scandalous of all, a decision that is the responsibility of independent judges is being discussed by Trendafilova with a group of diplomats, while she is totally influenced by prosecutor Jack Smith’s words.
Like a notary, Trendafilova sits silently as prosecutor Jack Smith speaks with conviction at this meeting, as if it were a foregone conclusion that the KLA leaders would be sentenced to life imprisonment.
The minutes do not show that she reacted even to Smith’s attacks on the defense teams, accusing the lawyers of wanting to delay the proceedings and thereby make release on bail possible.
Time would show that the proceedings would be delayed, far outside any international standard, by the prosecution itself and then by the panel of judges.
And Trendafilova never spoke about these delays, which weigh heavily on the lives of the four leaders of the Kosovo Liberation Army. Nor did she ever speak about proceedings that were extremely nontransparent to the public.
Nor did she ever speak about the defense’s serious concerns regarding proceedings that have gone off course, do not verify evidence from Serbia, criminalize the entire KLA, and disparage the testimony of international actors of the time; proceedings in which the judges, instead of challenging the prosecution, try to find incriminating statements about the accused and spend more time than the defense itself.
When the head of an institution, instead of guaranteeing the court’s independence, appears to be influenced by politics and external interests, and then uses her authority to make decisions that infringe on the rights of the accused and build a system of obstacles against the defense, the question that remains is simple: what kind of justice is this?








