When a Court of Appeals judge at the Specialist Chambers, Kai Ambos, spoke about the possibility of Hashim Thaçi being released to prepare his defence at liberty in a third country, the Court President, Ekaterina Trendafilova, changed the panel of judges. Kai Ambos was removed.
This is one of the troubling practices in a court that aims to deliver justice, which was cited on Thursday in The Hague by experts from “The Bar Human Rights Committee of England and Wales” (BHRC), during the presentation of the report on the Specialist Chambers.
Their 90-page report found violations of the rights of the accused in the judicial proceedings against former leaders of the Kosovo Liberation Army.
Another troubling aspect, mentioned by researchers Gus Waschefort and Lauren Lederle, was the lengthy questioning by judges, compared with the time given to the defence teams of the former KLA leaders.
According to them, this forced the defence to spend hours clarifying issues raised by the judges during the questioning of witnesses.
Meanwhile, the Prosecution used only a few minutes to respond to issues raised by the judges.
According to the researchers, this amounts to a lack of equality of arms between the parties, a principle guaranteed by international standards of justice.
At the conference, BHRC researchers also cited cases in which judges, particularly Guénaël Mettraux, asked leading questions during court hearings.
The December 2020 meeting between Ekaterina Trendafilova and Prosecutor Jack Smith with European Union ambassadors was described by the British researchers as unusual.
According to them, statements made there regarding whether or not KLA leaders would be released constitute a violation of the principle of the presumption of innocence.
The report’s presentation also found that documents obtained from Serbia and the acceptance of a large number of them without a full testing and verification procedure had been among the main points of contention.
The researchers stressed that accepting these documents is problematic, given Serbia’s position on Kosovo. According to the BHRC report, the Prosecution has used around 2,354 documents obtained from Serbia.
Representatives of the Specialist Chambers were also invited to this conference in The Hague. However, none of its representatives attended.
Kosovo Ombudsperson Naim Qelaj confirmed during the conference that the invitation had been sent to the Specialist Chambers, in his opening remarks.
Qelaj stressed that the report is authentic and independent, prepared by the BHRC without any interference from Kosovo institutions or any other body.
Diplomats from European Union countries, as well as representatives of the United States Embassy in The Hague, are attending the conference.









