On the defensive, particularly following the report by the organization “The Bar Human Rights Committee of England and Wales” (BHRC), which found violations by the Specialist Chambers in the trial of former leaders of the Kosovo Liberation Army, the President of the Specialist Chambers, Ekaterina Trendafilova, has published a video attempting to explain procedural matters, without addressing any of the criticisms made against it.
“I am responsible for the judicial administration of the Specialist Chambers, which includes, among other things, assigning judges to judicial proceedings, as provided for in the legal framework of the Specialist Chambers,” Trendafilova says about her work.
She notes that one of the most important aspects of a judicial institution such as the Specialist Chambers “is the independence, impartiality and professionalism of the judges—principles on which the Court was established and operates.”
She considers the judges’ reputation to be “untouchable.” “All judges have taken an oath to be independent of any external influence in the performance of their duties.”
This is precisely where the irony lies.
One of the main criticisms by the British lawyers concerns the expanded role of the judges, which, according to the report, risks undermining the fundamental principle of a fair trial: equality of arms between the parties.
The report notes that the judges are not limiting themselves to the role of neutral arbiters, but are actively intervening in the construction of the case. They have questioned witnesses for dozens of hours, often going beyond what the prosecution itself has presented. In some cases, according to the report, judges have used documents that were not part of the admitted evidence, including material obtained from the internet, without prior notice to the defense. Such a practice, the report says, “creates the conditions for the trial panel to function as a second prosecutor.”
“The Specialist Chambers’ framework gives the Trial Panel considerable discretion as the finder of fact and law. Without clear limits, this may create conditions for the Panel to function as a ‘second prosecutor’, affecting equality of arms. The defense faces not only the Prosecution’s case, but also that of the Trial Panel, with clear consequences for resources and strategy,” the report, which is over 90 pages long, states.
However, these concerns raised by the British lawyers are not addressed at all in Trendafilova’s statement, published on Sunday.
While praising their supposed professionalism and explaining the procedure for selecting them and the criteria they must meet to become part of the Specialist Chambers, she emphasizes that the judges’ responsibility is to “ensure that trials are safe and conducted fairly and independently, with full respect for the rights of the accused.”
Here too, she ignores the concerns repeatedly raised by legal experts at home and abroad over human rights violations against former KLA leaders, such as their lengthy pretrial detention, contrary to international standards, or the concealment of exculpatory evidence.
Following the report by the British lawyers, the Specialist Chambers made a series of public attempts to clarify its findings.
The Court also sent an email to the embassies of European Union countries accredited in The Hague regarding the report.









