Too good to be true. That is how the lecture delivered at Harvard School of Law in the United States of America by former Chief Prosecutor of the Kosovo Specialist Chambers, Jack Smith, sounded.
In response to questions from Alex Whiting, his right-hand man in The Hague in drafting the indictment against the leaders of the Kosovo Liberation Army, Smith spoke in this lecture about the proper theories and practices that make a prosecutor’s office serious, one that works with facts, does not persecute, and keeps its distance from politics.
And that is precisely where the irony lies.
A legal lesson from an extremely controversial figure, because of the methods applied in his project against the KLA, instituting political persecution, using evidence manipulated by Serbia, concealing strong exculpatory evidence, relying on false witnesses, and holding a show trial – a term that describes the model of trials in authoritarian countries, where the proceedings are entirely formal because the verdict is known from the outset.
Jack Smith:
“If you have a prosecutor who is so determined to achieve a particular outcome that they don’t care how they get there, you should be very suspicious of that prosecutor”.
This description, in fact, fits Jack Smith himself very well in terms of his work in The Hague.
He built an indictment that had no case.
Ben Emmerson, former lawyer for Kadri Veseli:
“Somehow, a case had to be created against these four men out of nothing”.
He distorted the facts.
Pierre Prosper, lawyer for Hashim Thaçi.
“Instead of letting the facts lead to the outcome, they have chosen to bend the facts to suit their desired ends”.
He opened the door to Serbia in the proceedings through materials against the KLA.
Gregory Kehoe, former lawyer for Hashim Thaçi:
“The threat here, from Serbian intelligence services seeking to infiltrate and obstruct justice in this case, is constant”.
And he did this despite it being common knowledge that Serbia constantly manipulated evidence against the Kosovo Liberation Army everywhere.
Ben Emmerson, former lawyer for Kadri Veseli:
“Many of which, in the past, under forensic examination, have proved to be misleading, fabricated, and a deliberate attempt to manipulate and deceive”.
According to findings by the defense teams, Smith also sought to protect part of the narrative in his indictment with false witnesses and intermediaries who had links to the Serbian Secret Service.
The Specialist Prosecutor’s Office repeatedly lied that it was prosecuting individuals, but in fact put the entire KLA in the dock.
Ben Emmerson, former lawyer for Kadri Veseli:
“What becomes clear when you read the material they have submitted is that the joint criminal enterprise they allege is, in itself, the Kosovo Liberation Army. The very existence of that group”.
When describing show trials – which take place in authoritarian countries – former prosecutor Smith mentioned something that he personally used as a method.
Jack Smith:
“Stalin had show trials. The Nazis had show trials. Most recently, Alexei Navalny in Russia. These are trials where the outcome is not in doubt and the process is whatever process is necessary to achieve the outcome you want”.
A month after the KLA leaders had been detained, when the trial was nowhere near ready to begin, the indictment was not complete, the evidence had not been presented and the witnesses had not been heard, in December 2020, Jack Smith had declared that Hashim Thaçi and Kadri Veseli would be sentenced to life imprisonment.
He had stated this as an accomplished fact at a meeting with Europe’s diplomatic corps, which was also attended by the President of the Specialist Chambers, Ekaterina Trendafilova.
Before representatives of democratic countries, Smith was presenting his position that the court proceedings would simply be a sham procedure, because the verdict was already known.
In the minutes of that meeting, published exclusively by Vox Kosova, neither Trendafilova nor the ambassadors are cited as having responded to Smith’s statement. This gives the impression that they all agreed to hold a show trial – where the proceedings are merely a formality because the verdict is already known and everything else must be made to fit it.
Nevenka Tromp, former investigator at the Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia:
“If the outcome of a trial has been predetermined and if the judges’ decisions and sentences in fact show that the KLA leaders will be sentenced to life imprisonment, unfortunately, we will have to conclude that these kinds of trials are show trials”.
The main point of Smith’s lecture at Harvard was this:
Jack Smith:
“Facts matter. Facts really matter.”
But facts were not the main point of his work in The Hague.
For more than two years, his office kept exculpatory evidence concerning the KLA leaders hidden.
This was highly significant evidence, such as a report by the U.S. CIA, a document from the State Department, and testimony from former OSCE ambassador Daan Everts, which said there was no evidence that the KLA was a structured organization and that, as such, it did not carry out organized attacks on civilians.
Gregory Kehoe, former lawyer for Hashim Thaçi:
“None of this was disclosed to us when we were exchanging and discussing this evidence. None of this was presented to you, Your Honour. None. And they have had this information for four years, while these four gentlemen have been in prison since November 2020”.
This act by the prosecution undermined not only the proceedings against the KLA.
Pierre Prosper, lawyer for Hashim Thaçi:
“The implications are such that they destroy, shake the foundations of the international justice system.”
Jack Smith’s prosecution team maneuvered over when the trial could begin, while Hashim Thaçi, Kadri Veseli, Jakup Krasniqi, and Rexhep Selimi were repeatedly denied release to prepare their defense at liberty.
Clare Lawson, prosecutor:
“In the view of the SPO, there is no reason why this case could not have started in the summer of 2021.”
Smith himself had also promised this in a filing of his in November 2020.
But these were lies.
Ben Emmeron, former lawyer for Kadri Veseli:
“They claimed they could be ready for trial in June of this year. That was a lie.”
In theory, for Smith, politics should be kept at a distance from the work of the prosecution.
Jack Smith:
“Keeping politics out of prosecutors’ decision-making matters.”
In his practice in The Hague, the opposite happened.
His actions against the KLA leaders were like a political battle.
Ben Emmerson, former lawyer for Hashim Thaçi:
“A decision had been made to arrest them even before the prosecution had begun analyzing its evidence. Why? Because they are well-known politicians”.
Smith issued the announcement of an indictment against Thaçi and Veseli like a bulletin, at a political moment, when the former president of Kosovo was traveling to Washington for a peace agreement with Serbia at the White House, in the presence of President Donald Trump.
Time would show that Jack Smith would be the prosecutor enlisted by politics to prosecute Trump for his political actions, and that his methods would closely resemble those he used in The Hague. For this, the Republican president and Republicans are calling for him to be imprisoned.
Donald Trump, president of the U.S.:
“In my opinion, the deranged Jack Smith is a criminal.”
When you hear Smith’s theoretical lectures and keep his machinations in The Hague in mind, the only comment is: Wow, Jack!








