Haxhi Shala has won his battle with the Ministry of Justice over a decision made against him during the time when Albulena Haxhiu was minister.
When former MP and one of the KLA commanders, Haxhi Shala, was accused by the Kosovo Specialist Chambers of offenses against the administration of justice on December 6, 2023, a few weeks later the ministry decided to provide financial support for his defense of just 1,000 euros per month.
It did so by invoking the new 2024 administrative instruction, which amended a 2022 instruction and limited support in cases involving charges against the administration of justice.
Moreover, this amendment also restricted support for KLA leaders and other cases involving war crimes charges, removing the possibility of allowing additional funds in exceptional cases. Defense lawyers had objected to this, but Haxhiu had not taken their concerns into account.
But why did the Court rule in Haxhi Shala’s favor, and what was Albulena Haxhiu’s role?
The Administrative Court has emphasized that the agreement offered by the Ministry of Justice in February 2024, providing support of 1,000 euros per month, was inconsistent with other practices for similar charges—as in the case of Nasim Haradinaj, who was given 81,000 euros per month for lawyers—as well as with the 2022 Instruction.
According to the ruling obtained by VOX Kosova, the Court finds that the 2022 Instruction was also in force and applicable in Shala’s case, not the 2024 one.
When the ministry decided that support would be only 1,000 euros per month, Shala appealed to the ministry on February 21, 2024, through his lawyer.
This appeal was also rejected.
“The respondent deliberately failed to consider the request in accordance with Administrative Instruction No. 08/2022, because the claimant submitted the request for compensation to the respondent before Administrative Instruction No. 01/2024 entered into force, while Administrative Instruction No. 08/2022 was in force. In addition to wrongly applying the Administrative Instruction, the respondent unjustifiably determined the level of the case, because the claimant’s case should have been classified as complex under Administrative Instruction No. 08/2022,” states the ruling of the Administrative Court issued on November 8, 2026.
Shala’s appeal against the decision of the Ministry’s Assessment Commission, which was responsible for determining the amount of financial support, was rejected by Albulena Haxhiu herself, then the minister, through a decision.
“The Court has established that the Ministry of Justice, through the Minister of Justice Albulena Haxhiu, by Decision No. 43/2024, dated 29.02.2024, rejected as unfounded the appeal by the claimant Haxhi Shala’s lawyer for coverage of the legal defense expenses of persons potentially accused of the alleged crimes in judicial proceedings before the Specialist Chambers. The reasoning of this Decision states that the Commission for Review and Decision-Making reviewed the request and documentation submitted by the claimant’s defense lawyer for coverage of expenses and, taking into account this general factor, as well as the number and nature of the charges in the indictment, decided that payment for legal defense compensation would be made in accordance with Administrative Instruction No. 01/2024, in the amount of 1,000 euros,” the Court explains in its ruling.
The Court has explained why the 2022 instruction, rather than the new 2024 instruction, which had been in force since February 7, 2024, applied in Shala’s case.
In addition to the request for compensation having been made before it entered into force, according to the Court, under the 2022 instruction, the procedures, conditions and criteria apply from the moment the indictment was filed.
The indictment was filed on December 6, 2023, and made public on December 12, 2023.
The Court writes: “This Instruction defines the rights and responsibilities of the entities for the purpose of processing requests for coverage of legal defense expenses before the Specialist Chambers. Article 4, paragraph 1 of this Instruction stipulates that persons potentially accused are treated equally and that any kind of discrimination against them is prohibited. Article 5 stipulates that ‘The Government, through the Ministry of Justice, ensures coverage of the legal defense expenses of a person potentially accused, in accordance with the conditions and criteria set out in Law No. 05/L-053, Law No. 05/L-054 and the Rules of Procedure of the Kosovo Specialist Chambers, and this coverage begins from the moment the indictment is filed.’”
The Court then explains that the new Instruction entered into force only on February 7, 2024, that is, two months after the indictment was filed.
“The Court clarifies that, in the present case, it is unclear why the respondent’s Commission did not apply Instruction No. 08/2022, given that this Instruction’s applicability to the coverage of expenses begins at the time the indictment is filed, as provided for in Article 5. The Court considers that, under this provision, the time the indictment is filed determines the starting point for coverage of expenses, whereas the indictment against the claimant was filed before Administrative Instruction No. 01/2024 entered into force, the Instruction applied by the respondent. Article 2 of the Administrative Instruction stipulates that the party’s submission of a request constitutes only a procedural condition for initiating the procedure for compensation of expenses, which means that the respondent does not act on its own initiative, but only at the request of a party. However, the request submitted must be assessed in relation to Article 5 of Instruction No. 08/2022, which stipulates that coverage of expenses begins from the filing of the indictment,” the Court’s ruling states, deeming the ministry’s decision legally flawed.
The Court has ordered the ministry to reconsider the claimant’s request, in this case Shala’s, and review it in accordance with the 2022 Instruction.
“In this regard, the Court orders the respondent, within thirty (30) days, to act in the renewed proceedings in accordance with the observations set out in this judgment and, after remedying the stated deficiencies, to issue a lawful decision. The observations set out are binding on the respondent body, pursuant to Article 65 of the Law on Administrative Conflicts,” the ruling states.
The Specialist Court, based in The Hague, sentenced Haxhi Shala to three years in prison in February 2025. On February 10, 2026, he was released from prison on parole.









