The draft law amending and supplementing the Law on the Specialist Chambers provides for narrowing the Specialist Chambers’ jurisdiction exclusively to offences related to the trafficking and removal of human organs, shortening the mandate’s time period from 1998 to July 1999, reducing the maximum sentence from life imprisonment to 15 years, transferring to Kosovo cases that do not fall within its jurisdiction, serving sentences in Kosovo’s correctional facilities, and the possibility of individual pardons by the President.

The draft law amending and supplementing the Law on the Specialist Chambers, initiated by the Democratic Party of Kosovo and approved by the Government to be sent to the Assembly for a vote, provides for putting the Specialist Chambers back on track, precisely with the cases for which it was established – those involving the alleged “organ trafficking”.

What are the Specialist Chambers and what do they do today?

The Specialist Chambers and the Specialist Prosecutor’s Office are a court established by Kosovo law, but with international judges and prosecutors and based in The Hague. They were established to deal with the alleged crimes in the 2011 Council of Europe report, which addresses the inhuman treatment of people and illegal trafficking in human organs during the war in Kosovo.

The Specialist Chambers’ mandate currently includes crimes against humanity, war crimes and certain offences against the administration of justice, for the period from 1 January 1998 to 31 December 2000. The maximum sentence is life imprisonment.

But what does the new draft law aim to do?

The purpose of this draft law is set out in Article 1. It states that it is intended “…to limit the jurisdiction of the Specialist Chambers and the Specialist Prosecutor’s Office exclusively to the specific criminal offences set out in the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Report, Doc. 12462, and to establish the procedure for the mandatory transfer of all other proceedings to the regular courts of the Republic of Kosovo”.

The draft itself explains that it aims “to prevent the institutional degradation of the Specialist Chambers into an extraordinary court, which is prohibited under Article 103(7) of the Constitution”. It also aims “to reaffirm the institutional primacy and primary responsibility of the regular domestic courts”.

Main changes

Jurisdiction over fewer offences.

Under this draft law, the Specialist Chambers would have jurisdiction over only two groups of offences: the removal and trafficking of human organs, and murders, torture or inhuman treatment directly related to them.

Article 2 explicitly states that everything else falls outside the Specialist Chambers’ mandate.

“The Specialist Chambers and the Specialist Prosecutor’s Office shall have no subject-matter jurisdiction (ratione materiae) over general war crimes, crimes against humanity or political violence committed in Kosovo that do not constitute a direct and constituent element of the specific acts…”.

It emphasizes that neither the “broader political context” nor the “generalized armed conflict” confers jurisdiction under this Law.

The time period is limited

The Specialist Chambers has a mandate to investigate cases dating from January 1998. However, under the new draft law, the start date is moved to 1 July 1999.

Under Article 3, the Specialist Chambers would have jurisdiction “…only over the crimes defined in Article 6(1) of this Law that occurred between 1 July 1999 and 31 December 2000”.

Sentencing threshold

The draft law provides that the maximum prison sentence would be 15 years, as opposed to the life imprisonment currently available.

Article 15 states that “…a prison sentence of no more than fifteen (15) years, in accordance with the principle of applying the more lenient law (lex mitior)”.

Sentences would be served in Kosovo’s correctional facilities, and those convicted could be pardoned by the President of the Republic, unlike under the current law.

“A prison sentence imposed by the Specialist Chambers shall be served in the correctional facilities of the Republic of Kosovo, in accordance with the legislation in force in the Republic of Kosovo. The specific correctional facility shall be designated by the competent authority of the Republic of Kosovo, taking into account the length of the sentence, security conditions and the individual circumstances of the convicted person,” Article 16 states.

“Notwithstanding the provisions of Law No. 03/L-101 on Pardon, persons convicted by a final judgment of the Specialist Chambers may be subject to an individual pardon by the President of the Republic of Kosovo. The criteria, conditions and procedures set out in Law No. 03/L-101 on Pardon shall also apply to persons convicted by the Specialist Chambers,” Article 17 states.

How would it work in practice?

Every case would undergo a jurisdictional test. At every stage of the proceedings, a judge or panel examines whether the charges fall within the mandate. A decision is made within 15 days, or 30 days if a hearing is held. If they do not, under Article 6, the panel “…shall immediately declare itself incompetent and order the termination of proceedings before the Specialist Chambers”.

For each person and each count of the indictment, the court must establish, under Article 13, a “concrete, direct and necessary link” to the allegations in the Council of Europe Report.

Cases that fall outside the report’s allegations are transferred to Kosovo.

Trials go to the courts in Kosovo, and investigations to the Kosovo Special Prosecution Office.

The receiving authority, under Article 7, “shall independently decide on jurisdiction, the procedural status of the indictment, criminal responsibility, and the admissibility of evidence”, while the transfer “does not predetermine the evidentiary value, legality or admissibility” of the materials.

What happens to the cases currently under way at the Specialist Chambers?

Ongoing cases continue under the old law until the Appeals Panel delivers its judgment.

After that, under Article 26, appeals go to Pristina and, under Article 26, “the Supreme Court Panel of the Specialist Chambers shall have no jurisdiction over these cases”.

The cases go only to the Supreme Court of Kosovo, which has exclusive jurisdiction to decide on further proceedings.

“From the date on which the Appeals Panel of the Specialist Chambers delivers its judgment, this Law shall apply to any further proceedings. Any appeal, request for protection of legality or other legal remedy against that judgment shall be filed with and reviewed by the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kosovo in Pristina, which shall have exclusive jurisdiction to decide on further proceedings,” Article 26 states.

The initiative to amend and supplement the Law on the Specialist Chambers was undertaken after the Specialist Chambers, in a scandalous decision, sentenced former Kosovo Liberation Army leaders to a total of 81 years in prison.

It sentenced former Kosovo President Hashim Thaçi to 25 years in prison, former Assembly Speaker Jakup Krasniqi to 25 years as well, former Assembly Speaker Kadri Veseli to 18 years, and former Vetëvendosje Movement MP Rexhep Selimi to 13 years.