If there is one moment that demolished the architecture of the 27-year-old accusations against the Kosovo Liberation Army, it is Ben Emmerson’s five-minute confrontation with Fred Abrahams.
Defence counsel demolished the testimony of the Human Rights Watch representative, revealing that behind his “facts” there was just one source: Serbia’s propaganda apparatus.
Nevertheless, after this debacle, which he experienced under oath and in public, Abrahams is trying to rise again, encouraged by the verdict imposing capital sentences on the KLA leaders.
In a podcast from The Hague on October 8, he expressed his conviction that the sentence was expected and natural, while displaying unwavering confidence in the prosecution’s evidence, which includes his own untruths.
“I was following the case closely. And when I watched it, you could never know what was going to happen. Of course, I didn’t know the outcome, but when I looked at what had been presented, and some of it had been presented in closed sessions, I said: I think they will be found guilty,” Abrahams says.
Abrahams flies so high that he readily dismisses the testimony of figures such as Wesley Clark and James Rubin, treating them as political statements with no factual weight.
“I heard those testimonies and I said: I don’t think this will help their defence at all, because these are high-level politicians and diplomatic officials giving their opinions, all of them with personal interests, because, for example, Wesley Clark was defending the signature campaign of his career, or Jaime Rubin and others. So, they didn’t seem at all convincing to me as far as the facts are concerned.”
At the same time, he gives the prosecution witnesses considerable credibility and authority, on the grounds that they were “people on the ground”.
“Whereas, on the other hand, you had prosecution witnesses from the UN, the OSCE and KFOR. You had diplomats who were more involved in operations and on the ground, who had daily interactions with the KLA and with the Serbs, and who also testified.”
The paradox here is absurd, of course.
Witnesses from American diplomacy and the military are declared to have “no knowledge of the ground”, despite the fact that they had an entire military and diplomatic apparatus reporting from the ground, while Abrahams himself—who admitted he had not visited the scene and had not interviewed a single witness—appears alongside others as a guardian of the truth.
In fact, this desire, this zeal of his to see the KLA convicted did not emerge after the verdict was announced.
Two days before September 16, in an opinion piece, he even took care to broaden the circle of guilt, accusing the West as well of tolerating crimes.
“Ultimately, the war crimes and crimes against humanity—those of murder, torture, persecution and disappearances—with which Thaçi and the others have been charged, were tolerated by governments that had intervened militarily against Milošević’s forces because of— as US President Bill Clinton put it—‘the moral imperative’,” he wrote.
The truth about Abrahams is that none of this is accidental.
He has always been on the side of speculation and manipulation when it came to the KLA.
“In April 2008, when Carla Del Ponte made claims about organ trafficking, Abrahams and Human Rights Watch rushed to lend them credibility, even claiming that they had previously had well-confirmed information.
“Human Rights Watch has obtained independent information and documentation that lends credibility to and confirms many things Del Ponte writes about post-war abuses in Kosovo.”
But what constituted “credibility” for Abrahams at the time? Serbian propaganda?
Probably, yes.
When Senator Dick Marty died, Abrahams declared him a “human rights hero” and praised his report on organ trafficking by the KLA—which, in fact, was never substantiated despite several investigations.
The only thing that was substantiated about that report was that it had been drafted using material from the Serbian prosecution and diplomacy.
Kosovo has seen this deliberate trajectory and construction, with a political agenda to convict the KLA.
It has seen it in the summary of the judgment, and will probably see it in the full version too, which will certainly be just like Abrahams’s report: rhetorical, unsubstantiated and completely wrong.








