The law on amendments to the Specialist Chambers, sponsored by the Democratic Party of Kosovo, is unconstitutional, and even the PDK itself knows that it is. But first, let us explain it in detail.
The first mistake is that the constitutional obligation arising from the International Agreement was not observed: the European Union must be consulted on legislative initiatives concerning the Specialist Chambers. Not obeyed, but consulted.
The exchange of letters of 14 April 2014 between President Atifete Jahjaga and the EU High Representative, Catherine Ashton, which was subsequently ratified as an International Agreement and which, under Article 19 of the Constitution, takes precedence over Kosovo’s laws, explicitly states: “We will undertake, in accordance with the Constitution… all commitments… including consultations in the process of amending and supplementing laws… initiated as a result of investigations by the SITF, the Special Investigative Task Force, whose investigations were subsequently inherited by the Office of the Specialist Prosecutor in The Hague, and an indictment was filed.”
So, you are constitutionally obliged to consult them. Not necessarily to listen to them. They do not get to veto what you do, but you must consult them. But this is only the first mistake, and not even the most serious one.
The direct conflict between the law and the Constitution is between Article 23 of the draft law and Article 162, paragraph 3, of the Constitution.
Article 162, paragraph 3, states: “A Specialist Chamber of the Constitutional Court, composed of three (3) additional internationally appointed judges, shall decide exclusively on constitutional referrals relating to the Specialist Chambers and the Specialist Prosecutor’s Office in accordance with the specific law”.
Referrals are submissions made to the court. In other words, cases.
Now, in Article 23 of the law, they have written: “The Specialist Chamber of the Constitutional Court shall have no jurisdiction to conduct abstract, concrete, incidental or any other form of review of the constitutionality of this law and Law No. 05/L-053”.
So, they are saying that by law they have decided to take away a power from an institution that was granted to it by the Constitution. You don’t need to be a lawyer to understand that the Constitution stands above the law and that you cannot take away by law what has been granted to you by the Constitution.
In an attempt to justify the mistake they made, Përparim Gruda issued an explanation in which he says that “the Constitution states that jurisdiction is exercised ‘in accordance with the specific law’, while the specific law determines what the Constitutional Chamber in The Hague reviews and what the Constitutional Court in Pristina reviews”.
No.
The specific law only regulates the exercise of the power; the law remains subordinate to the Constitution. In other words, the law regulates the referral procedure, the way you bring cases before the court, not the court’s jurisdiction. The article in the Constitution grants you the power; the law tells you how to exercise it.
The truth is that Përparim Gruda knows this too.
There are also many other mistakes, so blatant they seem intentional, such as the one concerning the imprisonment of convicted persons. While an international agreement, and therefore the Constitution, stipulates that convicted persons are imprisoned in a third country, here they have provided in the law that it will be in Kosovo.
And many other things that are so obviously wrong that it is difficult to believe these mistakes were made out of ignorance rather than malice.
Everyone in the PDK knows they got it wrong. They knew it even as they were doing it. I don’t know, and still can’t understand, WHY?
Why did they decide to put an end to the protest by deceiving the protesters? Why did they decide to deliberately cause this damage? Why did they bargain over a law with Kurti in exchange for the presidency, when, as they were writing it, they knew they were getting it wrong? Why did they deliberately reduce the protest’s demand to this badly written law? Why? Why? Why?
What is the deal?
I don’t know at present, but the authors of this scribble will be held accountable before the people for deciding to extinguish the citizens’ revolt, which stemmed from the pain of profound injustice, with a law that ends up in the trash, where its writers will end up too.








