In November 2016, David Schwendiman appeared before journalists for the first time in his role as Chief Prosecutor of the Kosovo Specialist Chambers.
Among other things, he drew a clear line between law and politics.
“I will make decisions based only on facts – the facts we have and will continue to gather – and on our best interpretation of the law, not on whether what I decide to do has political, diplomatic or other consequences or implications,” David Schwendiman.
Schwendiman had been appointed Chief Prosecutor for a four-year term.
But a phone call in February 2018, after just two years in office, marked an unexpected turning point in The Hague.
Apparently, in the corridors of Western diplomacy, expectations were that he would act with speedy indictments.
And his time in The Hague came to an end.
“I did not resign – my government simply told me my time was up, and I accepted that,” David Schwendiman.
The stage was set for Jack Smith – the controversial prosecutor who, in less than two years, compiled an indictment encompassing all the cases previously handled by international justice and justice in Kosovo, portraying the KLA as a “Joint Criminal Enterprise”.
He would issue the announcement of the indictment in June 2020, just as an important meeting between Kosovo and Serbia was being prepared at the White House, in the presence of President Donald Trump.
For Schwendiman, justice could not be done in haste and without strong evidence.
He shared this reflection shortly after completing his term.
“I instructed that a further assessment be conducted to determine whether indictments should be brought, namely whether a proposed charge is supported by: evidence that will be available to present at trial; and evidence that, after being subjected to scrutiny by a well-informed, responsible and determined defence, is likely to be sufficient, both in quantity and quality, to result in the accused being found guilty, in relation to each accused and each proposed charge for confirmation, with convictions that could withstand appeal,” David Schwendiman.
Between the lines, he signalled that European diplomacy was calling for action at all costs and as quickly as possible.
“Well-intentioned donors should be careful not to make institutions such as the Office of the Prosecutor even more vulnerable by failing to understand the nature of criminal investigations and prosecutions for atrocity crimes, and by demanding more of them than they can deliver. They may expect investigations and prosecutions to be completed within a relatively short time, with resources that might be sufficient in cases where a consolidated judicial system exists,” David Schwendiman.
After Schwendiman’s departure in May 2018, Jack Smith was appointed to head the Office of the Prosecutor – a figure whose methods would later be contested.
Smith quickly drafted an indictment, announced it publicly before it was fully ready, arrested the four KLA leaders, readily portrayed the KLA as a criminal enterprise and maintained a strong reporting line with the European Union.
A month after Thaçi, Veseli, Krasniqi and Selimi were sent to The Hague, in December 2020, Jack Smith and the President of the Specialist Chambers, Ekaterina Trendafilova, met with ambassadors of EU countries, the Specialist Chambers’ funders.
There, before the trial had even begun, before evidence and witnesses had been heard and before the defence had responded, life sentences were handed down for the KLA leaders.
Later, Jack Smith would leave The Hague for his new mission in the US to prosecute Donald Trump – the man who had disrupted his June 2020 meeting.
The trial in The Hague would not begin for another three years, and even when it did, it was conducted largely behind closed doors, with coordinated actions by mechanisms within the Specialist Chambers and outside them in the EU.
On September 16, following proceedings marked by numerous violations also identified by international organisations, the verdict was announced, unsupported by evidence anywhere.
What began in 2016 as David Schwendiman’s promise of fact-based justice, separate from politics, turned into a process in which, apparently, donor pressure and political interests determined the judge’s gavel, demonstrating that when politics entered through the courthouse door, justice was the first to flee.








