When UÇK leaders were convicted on 16 September, the United Kingdom responded through its Minister for Europe, Lord Wood of Anfield, supporting the decision and expressing support for the independence of the court and the proceedings.

But there is a clear hypocrisy between this stance and the facts that reveal Britain’s real approach to the independence of the judiciary in Kosovo, as well as to international justice.

In testimony by Briton Malcolm Simmons, former President of EULEX judges, it is stated that the British Embassy in Kosovo was regularly involved in the work of prosecutors and other British officials serving in the justice sector within EULEX.

In Simmons’s statement, obtained by VOX Kosova and also filed with the Specialist Chambers in 2021, when Nasim Haradinaj’s defence sought the removal of Charles Smith from the panel of judges, he says that the former British ambassador in Pristina and other embassy officials regularly met with prosecutors and discussed sensitive investigations.

“Under the then British Ambassador, Ian Cliff, I was expected to attend a weekly meeting at the British Embassy in Pristina, known as the ‘high-level British’ meetings. The information discussed was often sensitive and, in some cases, restricted,” Simmons stated.

According to him, issues concerning high-level and prominent politicians were discussed there.

“I was always asked about ongoing criminal cases, particularly when they concerned individuals of special interest to the international community. By ‘special interest’ I mean high-profile politicians,” Simmons testified.

Furthermore, he states that during these meetings, British prosecutors also discussed ongoing criminal investigations, including the examination of evidence, among it sensitive reports.

The former head of EULEX judges also stresses that the embassy took an active interest in criminal cases, and that British prosecutors would sometimes meet separately with senior embassy officials, including the ambassador himself.

The United Kingdom has followed this practice with the Specialist Chambers as well, although not at the same pace.

In May last year, British Ambassador Jonathan Hargreaves announced that he had met the President of the Specialist Chambers, Ekaterina Trendafilova, at the Embassy, once again expressing support for the independence of the institution.

VOX Kosova sent questions to the British Embassy in Pristina concerning Simmons’s claims. However, by the time this video was produced, the embassy had not provided any comment.

While London preaches “the independence of justice” in Pristina, there have been cases in which its policy has exerted direct pressure on international justice.

When International Criminal Court Chief Prosecutor Karim Khan was preparing arrest warrants for Israeli leaders over the war in Gaza, former British Foreign Secretary David Cameron called him, threatening him with diplomatic and financial consequences.

Media outlets that reported on the call, which the British government itself later confirmed, said Cameron’s approach to the Chief Prosecutor was aggressive in tone as well.

Contrary to what the government believes, however, a prestigious organisation in Britain, the Human Rights Committee of England and Wales, had voluntarily monitored the proceedings in The Hague. Its report raised serious concerns about human rights violations, a lack of transparency, inequality between the parties, judges with a biased outlook, secret meetings with diplomats that revealed dependence, as well as the use of unverified evidence during the proceedings.

Understandably, the questions for British diplomacy, so keenly interested in independent and impartial justice, are: Does it trust its own organisation, which is part of the official British legal profession established in 1894?

And before rushing to welcome the decisions of a controversial process, has it ever looked at the arguments of the other side, or is justice only valid when it serves geopolitics?