About two dozen films topped the box office in 2025, and it is safe to say that Paul Thomas Anderson’s One Battle After Another is the only one to show its protagonists freeing immigrants detained in detention centers.
The film has little competition for the title of the year’s most political movie; superhero films like Captain America: Brave New World always tell the most harmless stories possible, even when they are supposed to deal with conspiracies in Washington; Sinners conceals big ideas within a crime and horror vampire story; even Mickey 17, another hugely expensive Warner Bros film by a beloved director with political overtones, has a science-fiction genre wrapping.
On the other hand, some right-wing commentators seriously suggested that Warner should have postponed the release of Anderson’s film after the shooting of Charlie Kirk, asking whether the film amounted to incitement to political violence.
Some fans of the film have also described it in these terms; not as a call for violence, but as a rare major-studio project bold enough to take a stronger political stand than “we can all agree that extremist-fueled racism can, in certain circumstances, sometimes be dangerous to some people, perhaps.” Yet One Battle After Another is more complicated than it seems at first glance; this is also part of what makes it such an exciting work.
In broad outline, the heroes are left-wing radicals, facing an authoritarian movement within the U.S. government. Bob Ferguson (Leonardo DiCaprio) and his daughter Willa (Chase Infiniti) live under false names in the (fictional) town of Baktan Cross, after the breakup of the revolutionary group French 75, of which Bob and Perfidia (Teyana Taylor), Willa’s mother, were members years earlier, before Colonel Lockjaw (Sean Penn) broke up the group.
“Years earlier” is the first sign that the film is set in a heightened, alternate version of our world.
The film is “inspired by” Thomas Pynchon’s 1990 novel Vineland, about former radicals of the ’60s; bringing the story into the present day and accounting for Willa’s teenage age, the prologue takes place sometime during Barack Obama’s first term.
The film does not mention key events such as Obama’s election, the financial crisis at the end of Bush’s presidency, or the Iraq War. Instead, attacks on immigrant detention centers feel much more current today. It is not that immigrants were not detained in 2009 too—Obama oversaw many deportations—but the scene clearly capitalizes on the heightened attention to this issue today. Still, the film avoids direct references to Trump, Biden, the pandemic, or high-profile cases of police violence, creating a sense of a “perpetual present,” in which only the characters age and change.
Anderson often plays with time this way, as he did in Licorice Pizza. Here, time’s relentless forward movement serves the theme: the film is less a call for revolution than a reflection on the transition from youthful idealism to middle-aged caution.
Anderson sympathizes with the left-wing characters and mocks their opponents—a secret cabal of white supremacists called the Christmas Adventurers (“Hail, St Nick” is their absurd greeting). This normalization of revolutionaries is precisely what infuriates the right. But the left, too, might find it problematic that the French 75’s ideology is not explored in depth, that white supremacy is treated more as a ridiculous secret society than as a systemic policy, or that the focus is on Bob, a middle-aged white man, rather than the Black women who visibly carry the group on their shoulders.
Bob is portrayed as someone who is committed, but less convinced than Perfidia or the other comrades. He hesitates to return to action after Willa’s birth and is drawn toward a more private life. When forced to return, he clashes with the young people in the underground network. There is a running joke about Bob not remembering the right code to activate help, and Anderson treats this sympathetically, making the audience laugh along with his frustration.
In contrast, Sergio St Carlos (Benicio del Toro), a karate instructor who helps immigrants, is presented as a figure more practically engaged in the community. But Anderson has chosen to make the story about Bob and his relationship with his daughter: less about how to change the world than about how to protect his daughter from a world he failed to change.
This is also the crux: the way people often become more conservative as they age, focusing on their family. But Willa, as a self-assured young woman, carries the hope and burden of what is to come. Anderson is not offering a manual for rebellion, but a story about the transition between generations, with all its strengths and limitations.
In the end, One Battle After Another does not proclaim revolutionary victory, but an ongoing struggle. The weighty, deliberate title reflects precisely this: change is gradual, often defensive, sometimes powerless, but necessary all the same. Anderson does not celebrate political violence, but hopes the fight is not over. (The Guardian)









