It has been seven years since David Byrne released his last solo album, American Utopia. So much has happened in that time that it is easy to forget the album initially received mixed reactions. It was praised for its expansive, experimental approach: songs built on rhythms by Brian Eno were handed to a wide range of producers to reshape, and Byrne then selected the final versions. Part of a larger multimedia project called Reasons to Be Cheerful, the album aimed to bring a spirit of positivity. But there was criticism, too: some saw it as a naive abdication of responsibility at the height of Trump’s first presidency. Meanwhile, respectful reviews of his long career coexisted with indignation over the lack of female contributions.
Mixed reactions have been normal throughout Byrne’s career after Talking Heads. He has pursued a path taking in Latin American music, opera and trip-hop, collaborations with dance producers and with St. Vincent – but never with such overwhelming success as to eclipse the band’s legacy. Then something unusual happened: the live shows of American Utopia, which used advanced technology and choreography to break down the conventions of a rock concert, received rapturous praise. A tour that began in small theatres – ended up in huge arenas, became a Broadway show, spawned two live albums – one even named after a critic who called it The Greatest Live Show of All Time – and a film directed by Spike Lee.
So Byrne arrives with Who Is the Sky? at the peak of his reputation in the past 35 years. The album abandons the fragmented approach of American Utopia in favor of a more direct collaboration: the entire project was recorded with Brooklyn’s 12-member Ghost Train Orchestra and Harry Styles’s producer, Kid Harpoon. But the aim remains the same: more musical optimism in vivid colors. To that end, it uses a variety of sounds – mariachi horns on What Is the Reason for It?, orchestration with the flavor of 1940s Hollywood films on A Door Called No, rhythms linking Cuban tumbaos with George Michael’s Faith on Don’t Be Like That, or a strange vocoder soul inspired by Byrne’s former collaborator Thom Bell on I’m an Outsider.
Given that 2025 has been bleak so far, more so than 2018, it is understandable why Byrne thinks the world needs positivity. And Who Is the Sky? often sounds fantastic. The arrangements are excellent, especially when underpinned by the woody thumps of the double bass. The songs are often melodically strong. The climax of Everybody Laughs, with Byrne and St. Vincent bursting forth over a marimba-marked backdrop, is pure joy, as are the harmonic changes in the closing track The Truth. When We Are Singing works beautifully with its mix of a guitar line that recalls (perhaps unintentionally) Oasis and a tight funk rhythm – though it is debatable whether it really needed Byrne’s spontaneous meows.
Those meows also highlight the album’s main problem: the lyrics often veer into jokes. This works when the jokes are genuinely funny – as on Moisturizing Thing, where anti-aging cream apparently turns the protagonist into a three-year-old, leading to annoying retorts and constant demands for ID in bars. Or when they carry a more serious undertone: the man passionately singing to his apartment on My Apartment Is My Friend could easily be a recluse; the character bewildered by his partner’s knowledge of film, literature and human nature on She Explains Things to Me recalls Byrne’s own self-diagnosis of autism.
At other times, as on I Met the Buddha at a Downtown Party or The Avant Garde, they seem like forced attempts to lighten the mood. Likewise, optimism sometimes comes across as sweet to the point of naivety, without any shadow of darkness. In this respect, The Truth can be heard as either a love hymn or an admission that truth is increasingly fluid in a disinformation-filled world: “The truth can’t hurt me, I know what I know.” When We Are Singing at least acknowledges the bleakness – “we have one foot in the gates of heaven and the other in the flames” – while singing of music’s redemptive power.
It is hard not to have mixed feelings about Who Is the Sky?: a kind of normality for Byrne. But perhaps it is worth remembering the experience of American Utopia. Byrne has suggested that the upcoming tour will combine “visual art, storytelling and music in one spectacular show”. Judging by what happened last time – a good album that became something magnificent on stage – that sounds intriguing: a reason to remain optimistic. (The Guardian)








